The time has come: Sandberg or Posey?

SDS

I have right now:
C : Sanchez/IRod 91
1B: Olerud
2B: Didi
SS: Hanley
3B: Chipper
LF: Trammell
CF: Soto
RF: Jackson

Thanks for help

SDS

Sandberg, but I’m more worried about how in the hell you play with Soto in CF

SDS

@turtleopolis said in The time has come: Sandberg or Posey?:

Sandberg, but I’m more worried about how in the hell you play with Soto in CF

Never had an issue honestly i need a true cf just don’t see any I want to spend stubs on yet

SDS

I took Posey in my silver 1 choice pack. He's always been one of my favorite real life players. I figured he'd be a solid choice and perhaps the best catcher in the game for a long time however I'm starting to regret my choice. He never feels satisfying to hit with.

Soon I'm going to be stuck with the Jackson vs. Sandbeg choice and I'm not sure what I'll do.

SDS

Sandberg is a lot better than I thought he would be

SDS

I took posey, and have not looked back once. Dude mashes for me and has played excellent defense

SDS

Sandberg mashes with authority and plays diamond D.

SDS

Posey. You never have to worry about the catcher position again.

SDS

I went with Sandberg and he won a conquest game for me 1–0 first game in lineup

SDS

POSEY!!!

SDS

Posey is the safest choice especially if you play on HOF+. Gary is going to struggle

SDS

Offline guy here, took Posey and haven't regretted it for a second.

As for true CF, may I suggest taking FS Robles the next time you get Show Classics. He's a true CF who can hit well (obviously not power), is fast as hell, a good leadoff hitter, he's got Diamond defense, and best of all he's free.

Other suggestions are Mookie (yeah he's a RF but at CF he's got Gold defense), and Ketel Marte. Both are under 20 thousand stubs.

SDS

@JediEl1823 said in The time has come: Sandberg or Posey?:

Offline guy here, took Posey and haven't regretted it for a second.

As for true CF, may I suggest taking FS Robles the next time you get Show Classics. He's a true CF who can hit well (obviously not power), is fast as hell, a good leadoff hitter, he's got Diamond defense, and best of all he's free.

Other suggestions are Mookie (yeah he's a RF but at CF he's got Gold defense), and Ketel Marte. Both are under 20 thousand stubs.

I have Robles but he isnt even on team because I have Gimenez 93 as speed threat off bench. Just got McNeil as personal fav put him in LF for now and Trammell in CF.

SDS

I haven't hit well with Posey. I will admit that I'm not the best hitter though.
Posey seems to have a bunch of soft contact. Little bloopers and weak ground balls. I think I'm hitting .135 over about 150 ab's 3 hr.
Posey does play stellar defense!

SDS

Sandberg has been rock solid for me in 5 games and won 2 games alone on All Star. I’m very happy. If I get to Diamond 1 I’ll take Posey.

SDS

Posey has been so good for me, mainly contact wise. I haven’t even considered Sandberg because I have 99 Biggio already.

Log in to reply