I just did this, too. Mine was more idiotic. Bases loaded, deep fly ball off of Bumgarner into CF, I just assumed it was gone. Sent all my runners. CF leapt, made the catch, and they just threw the ball to 3rd, 2nd and first.
There should be a Mission for this with negative points.
I'm available for on-line games any time. I guarantee you'll see at least one entertaining play from me every time.