Dream starting 5

SDS

If every pitcher was available all time, all rated 99, who would be in your starting 5?

Mine is:
Roger Clemens
Vida Blue
Randy Johnson
Roy Halladay
Barry Zito ( totally doesnt stack up with the rest of my list but hes my all time favorite A, great personality and really fun to watch guys flailing at his curve)

SDS

Pedro
Randy
Greg Maddux
Fergie Jenkins
Mordechai "Three Finger" Brown

Just for fun...Kerry Wood or Jake Arrieta 🙂

SDS

Johan Santana
Prime Matt Harvey
Pedro Martinez
Tom Seaver
Sandy Koufax

Not necessarily in that order obviously.

SDS

Charles Radbourn
That’s all

SDS

Koufax
Pedro
Kershaw
Maddux
Seaver
(If I could choose a 6th I'd say Greinke just because I'm a huge fan)

SDS

@CRGDVD said in Dream starting 5:

Koufax
Pedro
Kershaw
Maddux
Seaver
(If I could choose a 6th I'd say Greinke just because I'm a huge fan)

Greinke is a beast, also following his career from the beginning it was awesome seeing how he was able to manage his social anxiety and continue to pitch

SDS

Pedro
Schilling
Maddux
Madbum
Clemens

SDS

@Kovz88 said in Dream starting 5:

@CRGDVD said in Dream starting 5:

Koufax
Pedro
Kershaw
Maddux
Seaver
(If I could choose a 6th I'd say Greinke just because I'm a huge fan)

Greinke is a beast, also following his career from the beginning it was awesome seeing how he was able to manage his social anxiety and continue to pitch

Very true... He's also an entertaining interview for his - let's say 'to the point' - responses.

SDS

Pedro Martinez
Randy Johnson
Chris Carpenter
Sandy Koufax
Roy Halladay

SDS

Pedro Martinez
Randy Johnson
Roy Halladay
Sandy Koufax
Greg Maddux

Tim Lincecum would be my 6th pick.

SDS

David Wells
David Cone
Mike Mussina
Andy Pettitte
Randy Johnson

SDS

@Quinn2161 said in Dream starting 5:

If every pitcher was available all time, all rated 99, who would be in your starting 5?

Mine is:
Roger Clemens
Vida Blue
Randy Johnson
Roy Halladay
Barry Zito ( totally doesnt stack up with the rest of my list but hes my all time favorite A, great personality and really fun to watch guys flailing at his curve)

The whole A's Big Three was fun to watch, I got to watch all of them play for the Canadians (Vancouver) from the minors up to when they won 20 games at one point for the A's. I'll never forget the run they went on in 2002.

Zito was a beast, his 2002 season is one of the best I've ever seen. 23 wins, 2.75 era, 180+ strikeouts

SDS

Sandy Koufax
Cy Young
Walter Johnson
Tom Seaver
Greg Maddux

SDS

Randy Johnson
Nolan Ryan
Roger Clemens
Greg Maddux
Pedro Martinez

SDS

@OUMarcus said in Dream starting 5:

Randy Johnson
Nolan Ryan
Roger Clemens
Greg Maddux
Pedro Martinez

This but replace Ryan with Koufax

SDS

Gerrit Cole
Gregg Maddux
Roy Halladay
Bob Gibson
Justin Verlander

SDS

@samguenther1987 said in Dream starting 5:

@Quinn2161 said in Dream starting 5:

If every pitcher was available all time, all rated 99, who would be in your starting 5?

Mine is:
Roger Clemens
Vida Blue
Randy Johnson
Roy Halladay
Barry Zito ( totally doesnt stack up with the rest of my list but hes my all time favorite A, great personality and really fun to watch guys flailing at his curve)

The whole A's Big Three was fun to watch, I got to watch all of them play for the Canadians (Vancouver) from the minors up to when they won 20 games at one point for the A's. I'll never forget the run they went on in 2002.

Zito was a beast, his 2002 season is one of the best I've ever seen. 23 wins, 2.75 era, 180+ strikeouts

For me it was Roger Clemens in 1986 24-4 2.48 era 248 K's whip 0.96 Boston should have won that WS. He was 23 years old

SDS

@samguenther1987 said in Dream starting 5:

Pedro Martinez
Randy Johnson
Roy Halladay
Sandy Koufax
Greg Maddux

Tim Lincecum would be my 6th pick.

Roger Clemens would be my 6th

SDS

@dbarmonstar said in Dream starting 5:

@samguenther1987 said in Dream starting 5:

@Quinn2161 said in Dream starting 5:

If every pitcher was available all time, all rated 99, who would be in your starting 5?

Mine is:
Roger Clemens
Vida Blue
Randy Johnson
Roy Halladay
Barry Zito ( totally doesnt stack up with the rest of my list but hes my all time favorite A, great personality and really fun to watch guys flailing at his curve)

The whole A's Big Three was fun to watch, I got to watch all of them play for the Canadians (Vancouver) from the minors up to when they won 20 games at one point for the A's. I'll never forget the run they went on in 2002.

Zito was a beast, his 2002 season is one of the best I've ever seen. 23 wins, 2.75 era, 180+ strikeouts

For me it was Roger Clemens in 1986 24-4 2.48 era 248 K's whip 0.96 Boston should have won that WS. He was 23 years old

That was before my time, but yes one of greatest seasons ever.

SDS

@dbarmonstar said in Dream starting 5:

@samguenther1987 said in Dream starting 5:

Pedro Martinez
Randy Johnson
Roy Halladay
Sandy Koufax
Greg Maddux

Tim Lincecum would be my 6th pick.

Roger Clemens would be my 6th

That's a toss up but Linecum was filthy during the playoffs so he gets the nod.

Log in to reply