Helton catches the ball. Won't throw it to 2nd no matter how many times I hit the triangle. I was looking right at the guy on 1st. He starts moving and I hit triangle. I hit triangle..again..again...Helton just saunters around like he's got all day, admires the ball for a bit, and then just tosses it to the pitcher.
Wasn't intentional AI spinning the game because next guy made an out..inning over. But, still a bug.