Who is the best duck on the pond player?

SDS

Any Reccomendations on whether to choose 97 McCutchen 97 Grienke or 98 Boggs?

SDS

Daniel Murphy is better than all 3 imo

SDS

@WillTheThrill_7 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

Daniel Murphy is better than all 3 imo

A man of honor right here

SDS

Grienke is my vote. Couldn't hit with McCutchen for some reason and sold him after going 1 for 14 or so.... Never tried Boggs. I got lucky with Grienke and Cutch in my 2 packs.

SDS

@WillTheThrill_7 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

Daniel Murphy is better than all 3 imo

While I respect your opinion, Cutch is the best player in the pack. I’ve only used Greinke for 1 start so I don’t really have an opinion on him. Murphy and Rodney are both better than Boggs though

SDS

Ordered best to worst
Base round: Daniel Murphy, El Duque, Rodney, Kingman, Salvy
Mid round: Greinke, Boggs, Cutch
Rare round: IDK but a 99 overall Jo Adell is BS

SDS

@the_dragon1912 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

@WillTheThrill_7 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

Daniel Murphy is better than all 3 imo

While I respect your opinion, Cutch is the best player in the pack. I’ve only used Greinke for 1 start so I don’t really have an opinion on him. Murphy and Rodney are both better than Boggs though

Cutch sucks swings a wet noodle , doesn’t have a good arm, has average speed..nothing special at all imo. I can find many cards that do the job. Rodney and Murphy are the best imo

SDS

@Therealest_JB said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

@the_dragon1912 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

@WillTheThrill_7 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

Daniel Murphy is better than all 3 imo

While I respect your opinion, Cutch is the best player in the pack. I’ve only used Greinke for 1 start so I don’t really have an opinion on him. Murphy and Rodney are both better than Boggs though

Cutch sucks swings a wet noodle , doesn’t have a good arm, has average speed..nothing special at all imo. I can find many cards that do the job. Rodney and Murphy are the best imo

I agree with what you say about Cutch in the field, personally I think he has. One if the best swings in the game. Cards perform differently for everyone though. I also think Murphy is a bit overrated but that is more due to overall underwhelming cards in the pack. He is still one of the better ones but a poor fielding second baseman doesn’t do it for me. His swing is one of the only universally loved swings I can’t hit with though

SDS

@the_dragon1912 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

@Therealest_JB said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

@the_dragon1912 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

@WillTheThrill_7 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

Daniel Murphy is better than all 3 imo

While I respect your opinion, Cutch is the best player in the pack. I’ve only used Greinke for 1 start so I don’t really have an opinion on him. Murphy and Rodney are both better than Boggs though

Cutch sucks swings a wet noodle , doesn’t have a good arm, has average speed..nothing special at all imo. I can find many cards that do the job. Rodney and Murphy are the best imo

I agree with what you say about Cutch in the field, personally I think he has. One if the best swings in the game. Cards perform differently for everyone though. I also think Murphy is a bit overrated but that is more due to overall underwhelming cards in the pack. He is still one of the better ones but a poor fielding second baseman doesn’t do it for me. His swing is one of the only universally loved swings I can’t hit with though

Well that’s what’s great about this game, we all perform uniquely with each card. That’s what makes a diverse lineup.

SDS

I loved SS Boggs last year, but there were just too many other good 3B for me to use him as much as I would have otherwise. When the Duck packs become old hat and he drops to under 20K then I’ll snag him. Until then, I’m not sure any of the high ( now mid) tier cards are worth what they’re selling for.

SDS

Zack Greinke

SDS

@SchnauzerFace said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

I loved SS Boggs last year, but there were just too many other good 3B for me to use him as much as I would have otherwise. When the Duck packs become old hat and he drops to under 20K then I’ll snag him. Until then, I’m not sure any of the high ( now mid) tier cards are worth what they’re selling for.

I always love Boggs cards. This one was too expensive for me to pick up though

SDS

@the_dragon1912 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

@WillTheThrill_7 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

Daniel Murphy is better than all 3 imo

While I respect your opinion, Cutch is the best player in the pack. I’ve only used Greinke for 1 start so I don’t really have an opinion on him. Murphy and Rodney are both better than Boggs though

I also respect your opinion but cutch is trash.

SDS

I only have the two that I took from my packs and I have been very pleased with them. I took Rodney and Murphy (Murphy plays 1B when in the lineup for ranked).

SDS

Probably Adam Banks. He was in all three movies.

SDS

@WillTheThrill_7 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

Daniel Murphy is better than all 3 imo

I haven't used McCutchen, but Murphy is incredible online for me... hitting bombs too, not just base hits.

SDS

@NWBearcat29 said in Who is the best duck on the pond player?:

Probably Adam Banks. He was in all three movies.

cake eater

Log in to reply