Who is the best of these three in your guy's experiences? I just gotta finish the Showdown tonight and will have my 300 stars. Using the two hitters in showdown has me thinking that Musial is by far the better hitter, but Rollins has more tools and is a switch hitter. Maddux on the other hand is just nasty even with the AI using him. I prefer to keep my boss and try to prestige them so selling him probably isn't gonna happen.