What High Rated Players do you SUCK with?

SDS

It pains me to say this but I am simply awful with Mantle. Had him for a week or so and batting .240 something. What makes me even more irate is that I sucked with Honus last year. I'm also terrible with Sheffield, Ortiz, and Henke.

Henke throws BP.

Interested in what y'all have. Can anyone join the Mantle club with me?

SDS

Awards McCutchen. When I got him I was stoked; then went 2-for-24.

SDS

Reggie Jackson. Him and his beyond slow log don’t even make the bench

SDS

I hate Buster Posey.... There, I said it.

SDS

@KOTANK1334 said in What High Rated Players do you SUCK with?:

I hate Buster Posey.... There, I said it.

I stink with regular Posey, FOTF Posey, and Awards Posey. Basically, all of the Posey's.

SDS

Posey....more like Poser... am i right ?!?!?!?

SDS

Not so bad with prestige Posey

Unfortunately I seem to get lit up with Rivera if there's a save opportunity.

SDS

reggie, ortiz, Mantle. Do 1000000000x better with guys with quick swings. Pizza is the worst by far. You could throw me pure meatballs with him and I would strike out 10/10 times.

SDS

Schmidt and Eric Davis

SDS

@theman925 said in What High Rated Players do you SUCK with?:

Reggie Jackson. Him and his beyond slow log don’t even make the bench

Me too. And Minnie minoso

SDS

@KOTANK1334 said in What High Rated Players do you SUCK with?:

I hate Buster Posey.... There, I said it.

Yeah he stinks too I don’t care what the attributes say

SDS

@dantheranman said in What High Rated Players do you SUCK with?:

Not so bad with prestige Posey

Unfortunately I seem to get lit up with Rivera if there's a save opportunity.

Forgot Rivera.... How do they mess up the greatest closer in the history of the game and make him so hittable ???

SDS

Oh, and Smoltz! But that’s event only that I’ve used him

SDS

Mr. October and Ryno. I don’t mind so much since I’m great with Walker and Biggio.

SDS

Can't pitch with Kluber to save my life.

SDS

@KOTANK1334 said in What High Rated Players do you SUCK with?:

@dantheranman said in What High Rated Players do you SUCK with?:

Not so bad with prestige Posey

Unfortunately I seem to get lit up with Rivera if there's a save opportunity.

Forgot Rivera.... How do they mess up the greatest closer in the history of the game and make him so hittable ???

Honestly he just doesnt translate well because he threw two pitches 90% of his career. Never over 97-98 and a readable motion. The team did their best to make him op.

SDS

Awards Kris Bryant, and it kills me as a Cubs fan cause I want him on the squad.

SDS

Reggie is ok offensively but the defense is absolutely terrible

SDS

@olivegarden2 said in What High Rated Players do you SUCK with?:

Reggie is ok offensively but the defense is absolutely terrible

He's been the most disgusting first bat off the bench for me since replacing him with Walker in the field. Legit seems like hes automatic xbh when pinch hitting.

SDS

@ZFree1122 said in What High Rated Players do you SUCK with?:

@olivegarden2 said in What High Rated Players do you SUCK with?:

Reggie is ok offensively but the defense is absolutely terrible

He's been the most disgusting first bat off the bench for me since replacing him with Walker in the field. Legit seems like hes automatic xbh when pinch hitting.

Yeah, him and Giambi against righty’s are amazing. I just can’t stand that fielding. I have LS trout in left, FOTF Davis in center, and prestige a Belli in right. You can tell I like good defense in the outfield lol

Log in to reply