Do you think next years game?

SDS

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

SDS

Eight games you struck out 7 of the 9 batters and had 7 good/squared up outs? 8 games played out that exact way out of 10?

It's fairly obvious that lineouts have been an issue in 19, the hitting engine is severely flawed. But come on, I don't believe that for a second.

SDS

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

let's just hope that next years game is a LOT BETTER than your subject header

SDS

@TheHungryHole said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

let's just hope that next years game is a LOT BETTER than your subject header

Do you think this comment?

SDS

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

SDS

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

I wouldn't say straight garbage, it's better than 18, and that is literally a fact. Half of this board doesn't even recognize 18. At least 19 will be known for stepping the franchise back in the right direction.

SDS

@Ikasnu said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

I wouldn't say straight garbage, it's better than 18, and that is literally a fact. Half of this board doesn't even recognize 18. At least 19 will be known for stepping the franchise back in the right direction.

Your facts are wrong. This year is worse than 18, arguably the worse ever. I strictly play DD RS, so its strictly from that perspective, and not any of the other game modes including franchise.

SDS

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@Ikasnu said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

I wouldn't say straight garbage, it's better than 18, and that is literally a fact. Half of this board doesn't even recognize 18. At least 19 will be known for stepping the franchise back in the right direction.

Your facts are wrong. This year is worse than 18, arguably the worse ever. I strictly play DD RS, so its strictly from that perspective, and not any of the other game modes including franchise.

I couldn’t even assemble a team to play DD in 18. The grind was too much for too little.

SDS

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@Ikasnu said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

I wouldn't say straight garbage, it's better than 18, and that is literally a fact. Half of this board doesn't even recognize 18. At least 19 will be known for stepping the franchise back in the right direction.

Your facts are wrong. This year is worse than 18, arguably the worse ever. I strictly play DD RS, so its strictly from that perspective, and not any of the other game modes including franchise.

Yeah no, you’re clearly the one in the wrong here.

SDS

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@Ikasnu said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

I wouldn't say straight garbage, it's better than 18, and that is literally a fact. Half of this board doesn't even recognize 18. At least 19 will be known for stepping the franchise back in the right direction.

Your facts are wrong. This year is worse than 18, arguably the worse ever. I strictly play DD RS, so its strictly from that perspective, and not any of the other game modes including franchise.

There are so many reasons this isn't true that it isn't even funny

SDS

It's just human nature, as time goes by people believe the current situation is "worse", despite the fact that MLB 18 was pretty awful.
If the people that were playing 19 were instead playing 18 and invested emotionally in that, they'd say 18 was worse.

SDS

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@Ikasnu said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

I wouldn't say straight garbage, it's better than 18, and that is literally a fact. Half of this board doesn't even recognize 18. At least 19 will be known for stepping the franchise back in the right direction.

Your facts are wrong. This year is worse than 18, arguably the worse ever. I strictly play DD RS, so its strictly from that perspective, and not any of the other game modes including franchise.

Yeah no, you’re clearly the one in the wrong here.

Yeah no, you're the one clearly in the wrong.

I said strictly from a DD RS perspective, and you're a CPU player, Playing CPU vs. online DD RS is like night and day, so you wouldn't be able to relate

SDS

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@Ikasnu said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

I wouldn't say straight garbage, it's better than 18, and that is literally a fact. Half of this board doesn't even recognize 18. At least 19 will be known for stepping the franchise back in the right direction.

Your facts are wrong. This year is worse than 18, arguably the worse ever. I strictly play DD RS, so its strictly from that perspective, and not any of the other game modes including franchise.

Yeah no, you’re clearly the one in the wrong here.

Yeah no, you're the one clearly in the wrong.

I said strictly from a DD RS perspective, and you're a CPU player, Playing CPU vs. online DD RS is like night and day, so you wouldn't be able to relate

I’ve played enough RS and events to know that 18 was far, far worse than 19.

A whole type of hitter was completely unusable in 18, yet you think 19 is worse.

18 had abysmally slow pitch speeds making fastballs even more ineffective than they are now. Defense didn’t matter at all in 18, and contact hitters were useless.

SDS

18 was so absolutely annoying to play. 95 percent of the runs scored in 18 came via the homerun. If you didnt have an all power team in 18, you were at a big disadvantage. 19 started off really well, but is now almost as bad as 18 was as far as needing homeruns to win. Not quite as bad though.

SDS

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@Ikasnu said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

I wouldn't say straight garbage, it's better than 18, and that is literally a fact. Half of this board doesn't even recognize 18. At least 19 will be known for stepping the franchise back in the right direction.

Your facts are wrong. This year is worse than 18, arguably the worse ever. I strictly play DD RS, so its strictly from that perspective, and not any of the other game modes including franchise.

Yeah no, you’re clearly the one in the wrong here.

Yeah no, you're the one clearly in the wrong.

I said strictly from a DD RS perspective, and you're a CPU player, Playing CPU vs. online DD RS is like night and day, so you wouldn't be able to relate

I’ve played enough RS and events to know that 18 was far, far worse than 19.

A whole type of hitter was completely unusable in 18, yet you think 19 is worse.
o
18 had abysmally slow pitch speeds making fastballs even more ineffective than they are now. Defense didn’t matter at all in 18, and contact hitters were useless.

19 has way more problems, not because I say so, but it's already been echoed throughout this forum. Excessive lineouts on perfect timing/pci placement, excessive pass balls (that little leaguers could block) and yet catchers like 99 Molina has trouble with, horrible pitch control for analog pitching despite control attributes by diamond pitchers, poor AI baserunning, inability to have sense of urgency to get rid of the ball on close plays, but instead player will hold onto the ball before getting rid of it, inability to tag runners out at times, etc., etc.,

Not gonna go back and forth, i'm done.

SDS

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@Ikasnu said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

I wouldn't say straight garbage, it's better than 18, and that is literally a fact. Half of this board doesn't even recognize 18. At least 19 will be known for stepping the franchise back in the right direction.

Your facts are wrong. This year is worse than 18, arguably the worse ever. I strictly play DD RS, so its strictly from that perspective, and not any of the other game modes including franchise.

Yeah no, you’re clearly the one in the wrong here.

Yeah no, you're the one clearly in the wrong.

I said strictly from a DD RS perspective, and you're a CPU player, Playing CPU vs. online DD RS is like night and day, so you wouldn't be able to relate

I’ve played enough RS and events to know that 18 was far, far worse than 19.

A whole type of hitter was completely unusable in 18, yet you think 19 is worse.
o
18 had abysmally slow pitch speeds making fastballs even more ineffective than they are now. Defense didn’t matter at all in 18, and contact hitters were useless.

19 has way more problems, not because I say so, but it's already been echoed throughout this forum. Excessive lineouts on perfect timing/pci placement, excessive pass balls (that little leaguers could block) and yet catchers like 99 Molina has trouble with, horrible pitch control for analog pitching despite control attributes by diamond pitchers, poor AI baserunning, inability to have sense of urgency to get rid of the ball on close plays, but instead player will hold onto the ball before getting rid of it, inability to tag runners out at times, etc., etc.,

Not gonna go back and forth, i'm done.

So MLB 18 didn't have things like "poor AI baserunning, inability to have sense of urgency to get rid of the ball on close plays, but instead player will hold onto the ball before getting rid of it, inability to tag runners out at times"

Because that's a pretty common problem over the entirety of the series and 19 defintely has those issues, but it ain't unique in those issues.

SDS

All gameplay aside 18 fails compared to 19 for one sole reason. Slow pitch speeds. That is reason enough for it, nevermind the fact that power was the only viable statistic and breaking balls were literally all you could throw.

SDS

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@Ikasnu said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

I wouldn't say straight garbage, it's better than 18, and that is literally a fact. Half of this board doesn't even recognize 18. At least 19 will be known for stepping the franchise back in the right direction.

Your facts are wrong. This year is worse than 18, arguably the worse ever. I strictly play DD RS, so its strictly from that perspective, and not any of the other game modes including franchise.

Yeah no, you’re clearly the one in the wrong here.

Yeah no, you're the one clearly in the wrong.

I said strictly from a DD RS perspective, and you're a CPU player, Playing CPU vs. online DD RS is like night and day, so you wouldn't be able to relate

I’ve played enough RS and events to know that 18 was far, far worse than 19.

A whole type of hitter was completely unusable in 18, yet you think 19 is worse.
o
18 had abysmally slow pitch speeds making fastballs even more ineffective than they are now. Defense didn’t matter at all in 18, and contact hitters were useless.

19 has way more problems, not because I say so, but it's already been echoed throughout this forum. Excessive lineouts on perfect timing/pci placement, excessive pass balls (that little leaguers could block) and yet catchers like 99 Molina has trouble with, horrible pitch control for analog pitching despite control attributes by diamond pitchers, poor AI baserunning, inability to have sense of urgency to get rid of the ball on close plays, but instead player will hold onto the ball before getting rid of it, inability to tag runners out at times, etc., etc.,

Not gonna go back and forth, i'm done.

You are acting like 18 didnt have these issues as well. I cant speak for analog pitching because I dont use it, but the tagging in 19 is extremely better than it was in 18. Catcher blocking is terrible in 18 and 19, so glad they worked on this for 20.

SDS

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@Ikasnu said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

I wouldn't say straight garbage, it's better than 18, and that is literally a fact. Half of this board doesn't even recognize 18. At least 19 will be known for stepping the franchise back in the right direction.

Your facts are wrong. This year is worse than 18, arguably the worse ever. I strictly play DD RS, so its strictly from that perspective, and not any of the other game modes including franchise.

Yeah no, you’re clearly the one in the wrong here.

Yeah no, you're the one clearly in the wrong.

I said strictly from a DD RS perspective, and you're a CPU player, Playing CPU vs. online DD RS is like night and day, so you wouldn't be able to relate

They are both really bad versions of the game. Like deciding what pile of [censored] to like.

SDS

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@DriveByTrucker17 said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@Ikasnu said in Do you think next years game?:

@onnagood1 said in Do you think next years game?:

@BigBadBosc44 said in Do you think next years game?:

After 3 innings i have struck out 7 of his nine hitters he has struck out 0 of my 9 hitters 7 of my outs good/squared up
But i am losing 1-0 eight of ten games i played was like that.

Did this happen to most?

Yes it does.

This game is straight garbage...Final Answer.

I wouldn't say straight garbage, it's better than 18, and that is literally a fact. Half of this board doesn't even recognize 18. At least 19 will be known for stepping the franchise back in the right direction.

Your facts are wrong. This year is worse than 18, arguably the worse ever. I strictly play DD RS, so its strictly from that perspective, and not any of the other game modes including franchise.

Yeah no, you’re clearly the one in the wrong here.

Yeah no, you're the one clearly in the wrong.

I said strictly from a DD RS perspective, and you're a CPU player, Playing CPU vs. online DD RS is like night and day, so you wouldn't be able to relate

I’ve played enough RS and events to know that 18 was far, far worse than 19.

A whole type of hitter was completely unusable in 18, yet you think 19 is worse.
o
18 had abysmally slow pitch speeds making fastballs even more ineffective than they are now. Defense didn’t matter at all in 18, and contact hitters were useless.

19 has way more problems, not because I say so, but it's already been echoed throughout this forum. Excessive lineouts on perfect timing/pci placement, excessive pass balls (that little leaguers could block) and yet catchers like 99 Molina has trouble with, horrible pitch control for analog pitching despite control attributes by diamond pitchers, poor AI baserunning, inability to have sense of urgency to get rid of the ball on close plays, but instead player will hold onto the ball before getting rid of it, inability to tag runners out at times, etc., etc.,

Not gonna go back and forth, i'm done.

Clearly you haven't been on the forums long. Almost everyone with the except of a few guys with some screws loose believe that 19 is a step in the right direction and is far better than 18. Catchers were even worse last year so that is off the table. this game has a lineout issue, but in all honestly on HOF and Legend it doesn't occur as much whereas in 18, you would have a good/good center pci 100 mph FB to then have an exit velo of 85. That occurred more than lineouts in 19. Pitch speeds were so slow on HOF and Legend in 18 that my Grandma could have early timing on a Legend FB. Zero skill gap in 18.

Log in to reply