Who do you prefer?

SDS

Would you rather have Stan Musial or Bryce Harper? I’m still like 70 stars away from Musial and only got like 20 stars in total toward Bryce since I am still grinding on the Babe program. I only got 6 more HOF games left on that so when I get done with that I was gonna try to pursue either Musial or Bryce. I like Musial bat but his defense looks suspect. Bryce looks like a more complete player. Any feedback would be appreciated. My outfield right now is Walker, Luis Roberts, and Christian Yelich.

SDS

Musial is great, but if this is to play in the outfield than Harper is the choice

SDS

@J_Gwalla09 said in Who do you prefer?:

Would you rather have Stan Musial or Bryce Harper? I’m still like 70 stars away from Musial and only got like 20 stars in total toward Bryce since I am still grinding on the Babe program. I only got 6 more HOF games left on that so when I get done with that I was gonna try to pursue either Musial or Bryce. I like Musial bat but his defense looks suspect. Bryce looks like a more complete player. Any feedback would be appreciated. My outfield right now is Walker, Luis Roberts, and Christian Yelich.

Musial is a great hitter. I hit better with him than babe. If you want musial and babe then put babe in rf and musial at 1b. Babe is faster and has better fielding, arm and reaction. I have no experience with harper yet.

SDS

Thanks for the responses. That’s a good idea to put Musial at 1st and Babe in the outfield (once I get him) I have 99 Thome at 1st. So I’m thinking about moving him to the bench if I get Musial and Babe. For whatever reason I don’t do great with Thome even though a ton of people love and rake with him. I’m just looking for a switch up.

SDS

Musial just doesn't have amazing pop vs RHP. Which u face a ton more! Where are u alone the prestige path? Cause springer and thames even jose ramirez u can play at 1B.. springer in OF!! Harper has better swing , speed, defense over musial! Thome way better hitter then musial! George Brett also way better then musial ! If I were u I would sell robert and musial! Get babe ruth to play at 1B!! Harper for RF. Or sell harper! In time u will have more options in OF !! 99 mays!! 99 andruw Jones! Mantle! 99 griffey !! 99 cobb who I think this year will be amazing !! Maybe 99 mookie! Finest cards! Team affinity stage 4 also !!

SDS

I've played with Ruth for a few games in right. His defense isn't going to cut it. I'll be moving him to first.

Go after Harper and use Ruth at first imo.

SDS

@high-heat-27 said in Who do you prefer?:

Musial just doesn't have amazing pop vs RHP. Which u face a ton more! Where are u alone the prestige path? Cause springer and thames even jose ramirez u can play at 1B.. springer in OF!! Harper has better swing , speed, defense over musial! Thome way better hitter then musial! George Brett also way better then musial ! If I were u I would sell robert and musial! Get babe ruth to play at 1B!! Harper for RF. Or sell harper! In time u will have more options in OF !! 99 mays!! 99 andruw Jones! Mantle! 99 griffey !! 99 cobb who I think this year will be amazing !! Maybe 99 mookie! Finest cards! Team affinity stage 4 also !!

Is your shift key broken? Sure a lot of (!).

Musial is the best pure hitter in the game, I doubt there will be another card that matches his hitting stats, 99 Trout doesn't, so I doubt anyone will. If you can't hit HR's with 125 contact, 98 power, and 118 vision, the problem isn't the card. Contact has more impact on HRs than power does this year anyway.

Get him, put him on first, don't think twice.

SDS

I mean, if you're running Yelich out in your outfield, having Ruth out there wouldn't be that much different defensively. I personally wouldn't do it, but I value outfield defense and speed a ton

SDS

@SaldanaBros5 said in Who do you prefer?:

I mean, if you're running Yelich out in your outfield, having Ruth out there wouldn't be that much different defensively. I personally wouldn't do it, but I value outfield defense and speed a ton

Yeah, I'm not alone! I'm running Mantle in LF, Robert in CF, and Pache in RF.

SDS

@lucas8181 said in Who do you prefer?:

@SaldanaBros5 said in Who do you prefer?:

I mean, if you're running Yelich out in your outfield, having Ruth out there wouldn't be that much different defensively. I personally wouldn't do it, but I value outfield defense and speed a ton

Yeah, I'm not alone! I'm running Mantle in LF, Robert in CF, and Pache in RF.

I love that outfield. I run out Robert, Adell, and Walker. I don't have Mantle, but im close to gettjng trout.

SDS

@SaldanaBros5 said in Who do you prefer?:

@lucas8181 said in Who do you prefer?:

@SaldanaBros5 said in Who do you prefer?:

I mean, if you're running Yelich out in your outfield, having Ruth out there wouldn't be that much different defensively. I personally wouldn't do it, but I value outfield defense and speed a ton

Yeah, I'm not alone! I'm running Mantle in LF, Robert in CF, and Pache in RF.

I love that outfield. I run out Robert, Adell, and Walker. I don't have Mantle, but im close to gettjng trout.

How is Adell for you? I might buy him today.

SDS

@lucas8181 said in Who do you prefer?:

@SaldanaBros5 said in Who do you prefer?:

@lucas8181 said in Who do you prefer?:

@SaldanaBros5 said in Who do you prefer?:

I mean, if you're running Yelich out in your outfield, having Ruth out there wouldn't be that much different defensively. I personally wouldn't do it, but I value outfield defense and speed a ton

Yeah, I'm not alone! I'm running Mantle in LF, Robert in CF, and Pache in RF.

I love that outfield. I run out Robert, Adell, and Walker. I don't have Mantle, but im close to gettjng trout.

How is Adell for you? I might buy him today.

Hitting 354 with 21 HRs in about 200 plus at bats. F
Defense is solid. His speed in the middle of the order is nice. I wish his vision was a bit higher, but nobody is perfect. I hit a ton of bombs to right center and left center for some reason. Also, I'm an angels fan so that why I bought him originally.

SDS

@SaldanaBros5 said in Who do you prefer?:

@lucas8181 said in Who do you prefer?:

@SaldanaBros5 said in Who do you prefer?:

@lucas8181 said in Who do you prefer?:

@SaldanaBros5 said in Who do you prefer?:

I mean, if you're running Yelich out in your outfield, having Ruth out there wouldn't be that much different defensively. I personally wouldn't do it, but I value outfield defense and speed a ton

Yeah, I'm not alone! I'm running Mantle in LF, Robert in CF, and Pache in RF.

I love that outfield. I run out Robert, Adell, and Walker. I don't have Mantle, but im close to gettjng trout.

How is Adell for you? I might buy him today.

Hitting 354 with 21 HRs in about 200 plus at bats. F
Defense is solid. His speed in the middle of the order is nice. I wish his vision was a bit higher, but nobody is perfect. I hit a ton of bombs to right center and left center for some reason. Also, I'm an angels fan so that why I bought him originally.

Has he given a lot of HR's to the other team with his fielding? JK, that was a fluke play, really weird.

Thanks man, I'll give him a go. I don't have much else to spend stubs on at this point.

SDS

@lucas8181 said in Who do you prefer?:

@SaldanaBros5 said in Who do you prefer?:

@lucas8181 said in Who do you prefer?:

@SaldanaBros5 said in Who do you prefer?:

@lucas8181 said in Who do you prefer?:

@SaldanaBros5 said in Who do you prefer?:

I mean, if you're running Yelich out in your outfield, having Ruth out there wouldn't be that much different defensively. I personally wouldn't do it, but I value outfield defense and speed a ton

Yeah, I'm not alone! I'm running Mantle in LF, Robert in CF, and Pache in RF.

I love that outfield. I run out Robert, Adell, and Walker. I don't have Mantle, but im close to gettjng trout.

How is Adell for you? I might buy him today.

Hitting 354 with 21 HRs in about 200 plus at bats. F
Defense is solid. His speed in the middle of the order is nice. I wish his vision was a bit higher, but nobody is perfect. I hit a ton of bombs to right center and left center for some reason. Also, I'm an angels fan so that why I bought him originally.

Has he given a lot of HR's to the other team with his fielding? JK, that was a fluke play, really weird.

Thanks man, I'll give him a go. I don't have much else to spend stubs on at this point.

Lmao he has indeed. It's been rough as an angel fan for years so nothing ever surprises me lmao. Yeah give him a go. He is low rn, because of the dotp packs available in coquest and events. Pick him up, and worst case if you don't like him, he will rise in price with 2-3 weeks

Log in to reply