ROY: Luis Robert or Kyle Lewis?

SDS

Lewis: .354/.440/.545 with 35 hits, 2 SB, 18 RBI, 6 HR

Robert: .275/.327/.538 with 25 hits, 4 SB, 15 RBI, 6 HR

Who do you like for rookie of the year?

SDS

Right now Lewis deserves it imo

But Luis Robert is more hyped, and Seattle sucks, so assuming numbers stay relatively the same, Robert will win it

SDS

@eatyum said in ROY: Luis Robert or Kyle Lewis?:

Right now Lewis deserves it imo

But Luis Robert is more hyped, and Seattle sucks, so assuming numbers stay relatively the same, Robert will win it

Yeah, I fear it will go that way as well. I think Lewis deserves it right now, but nobody cares about the M’s.

I just hope his card gets better. I think he is still a 68 OVR with 53 fielding and like a 37 arm.

SDS

Kyle Lewis is my hero.

SDS

@eatyum said in ROY: Luis Robert or Kyle Lewis?:

Right now Lewis deserves it imo

But Luis Robert is more hyped, and Seattle sucks, so assuming numbers stay relatively the same, Robert will win it

But those numbers presented in the OP aren't the same IMO.

SDS

@NCStateHokie said in ROY: Luis Robert or Kyle Lewis?:

@eatyum said in ROY: Luis Robert or Kyle Lewis?:

Right now Lewis deserves it imo

But Luis Robert is more hyped, and Seattle sucks, so assuming numbers stay relatively the same, Robert will win it

But those numbers presented in the OP aren't the same IMO.

Exactly. Lewis is definitely more deserving at the moment, but as eatyum pointed out, Luis Robert has a lot more media attention and hype.

Lewis with another three hits tonight now hitting .373.

SDS

@halfbutt said in ROY: Luis Robert or Kyle Lewis?:

@NCStateHokie said in ROY: Luis Robert or Kyle Lewis?:

@eatyum said in ROY: Luis Robert or Kyle Lewis?:

Right now Lewis deserves it imo

But Luis Robert is more hyped, and Seattle sucks, so assuming numbers stay relatively the same, Robert will win it

But those numbers presented in the OP aren't the same IMO.

Exactly. Lewis is definitely more deserving at the moment, but as eatyum pointed out, Luis Robert has a lot more media attention and hype.

Lewis with another three hits tonight now hitting .373.

I don’t care how hyped the guy is. If Lewis hits over .360 for the year, and Robert is under .300, I don’t see how Lewis doesn’t win. Especially in today’s world where only 3 people (or so) a year hit over .300!

SDS

Robert has the hype, but if we are basing it on actual facts, it’s Kyle Lewis.

SDS

Kyle Lewis. He is gonna be Griffey 3.0.

SDS

More like Adam jones 2.0... only trout is Griffey 2.0

SDS

Honestly I can’t believe the updates haven’t considered really any mariners players yet. Austin Nola is tearing the cover off the ball and is performing as a top 5 catcher and isn’t even a silver rating! Kyle Lewis is leading the league in hits and is still a bronze!!! All starting pitchers are very underrated as well, especially Marco Gonzalez. Just a shame.

SDS

Lewis is also top ten in war this year, currently number 9

SDS

@Lberrybats77 said in ROY: Luis Robert or Kyle Lewis?:

Honestly I can’t believe the updates haven’t considered really any mariners players yet. Austin Nola is tearing the cover off the ball and is performing as a top 5 catcher and isn’t even a silver rating! Kyle Lewis is leading the league in hits and is still a bronze!!! All starting pitchers are very underrated as well, especially Marco Gonzalez. Just a shame.

At least we got a decent Evan White card.
His LS card has 59 arm and 53 acc for an 80 rated defender on the 20-80 scale. This guy is easily the best defensive 1B in the game.

Kyle Seager finally got a gold card, but still has a 54 arm.

I think probably they decide about where they want the player OVR to sit and then create the attributes.

SDS

I completely agree about white, also Lewis is 2nd in offensive war only trailing yazatrzemski(doesn’t look right).

SDS

I think that Rookie Of The Year voters generally don't necessarily side with rookie players just because they happen to be helping their team win more games or stay in a playoff race. Chicago's lineup has likely given Luis Robert much more protection, which could make what Kyle Lewis is doing more impressive.

SDS

Kyle Lewis with another bomb today, insane.

SDS

Kyle Lewis WAR is higher than Betts and Harper 🤯

SDS

@Collin_SDS said in ROY: Luis Robert or Kyle Lewis?:

Kyle Lewis WAR is higher than Betts and Harper 🤯

When I saw that there was an SDS reply to something involving the Mariners, I thought “Collin must have said something” 🙂

SDS

Forget ROY: Lick Nivingston says Robert is the MVP:

https://youtu.be/soShwAKuIeQ?t=3127

SDS

@halfbutt said in ROY: Luis Robert or Kyle Lewis?:

@Lberrybats77 said in ROY: Luis Robert or Kyle Lewis?:

Honestly I can’t believe the updates haven’t considered really any mariners players yet. Austin Nola is tearing the cover off the ball and is performing as a top 5 catcher and isn’t even a silver rating! Kyle Lewis is leading the league in hits and is still a bronze!!! All starting pitchers are very underrated as well, especially Marco Gonzalez. Just a shame.

At least we got a decent Evan White card.
His LS card has 59 arm and 53 acc for an 80 rated defender on the 20-80 scale. This guy is easily the best defensive 1B in the game.

Kyle Seager finally got a gold card, but still has a 54 arm.

I think probably they decide about where they want the player OVR to sit and then create the attributes.

I completely agree!! They do what they want!

Log in to reply