Henderson or Matthews?

SDS

As of now, I’m sitting on 311,000 stubs. Not sure if I want to buy 99 Rickey Henderson or 99 Eddie Matthews so I’m looking for some suggestions. Right now my lineup is:

LF: 99 Stan Musial
CF: 99 Larry Walker
RF: 99 Bryce Harper
3B: 99 Ryne Sandburg or 98 Bo Bichette
SS: 99 Jimmy Rollins or 98 Bo Bichette
2B: 99 Rogers Hornsby
1B: 99 Babe Ruth
😄 CAP

SDS

@n_wiggins00 said in Henderson or Matthews?:

As of now, I’m sitting on 311,000 stubs. Not sure if I want to buy 99 Rickey Henderson or 99 Eddie Matthews so I’m looking for some suggestions. Right now my lineup is:

LF: 99 Stan Musial
CF: 99 Larry Walker
RF: 99 Bryce Harper
3B: 99 Ryne Sandburg or 98 Bo Bichette
SS: 99 Jimmy Rollins or 98 Bo Bichette
2B: 99 Rogers Hornsby
1B: 99 Babe Ruth
😄 CAP

**Catcher: CAP

SDS

Mantle - didi - trout

SDS

@MaxHarvest said in Henderson or Matthews?:

Mantle - didi - trout

I’m never gonna be able to afford Mantle or Trout

SDS

You need Mantle...that is all I will say! Your team looks amazing but clearly needs Mantle, you won't regret spending so much on one card

SDS

@olivegarden2 said in Henderson or Matthews?:

You need Mantle...that is all I will say! Your team looks amazing but clearly needs Mantle, you won't regret spending so much on one card

Id love Mantle but I just don’t really grind enough to get him. I have like 3 live series diamonds and don’t want to spend weeks on end trying to flip cards to afford Mantle

SDS

@n_wiggins00 said in Henderson or Matthews?:

@olivegarden2 said in Henderson or Matthews?:

You need Mantle...that is all I will say! Your team looks amazing but clearly needs Mantle, you won't regret spending so much on one card

Id love Mantle but I just don’t really grind enough to get him. I have like 3 live series diamonds and don’t want to spend weeks on end trying to flip cards to afford Mantle

You should just invest and sell a few cards you have

SDS

Eddie will luv you if u luv him.

SDS

Dude musial in LF sounds terrible. If you need to use him, throw him at 1b, babe in RF and harper in LF. Thats still a sketchy outfield. I love musial but no way he's playing the outfield. He's a bench bat if not at 1b. So many outfield options that you dont need to spend 300k on rickey or eddie at 3b. Try brett at 3b. Try lofton, gwynn, Robert in the outfield. Walker should be in RF. He isn't fast enough in CF imo. Good luck with what you choose.

SDS

Forget answers from people until you bless us with your avg ranking because if your AS it doesn't matter just get high velo pitchers with common squad your good to go. That's unless you run into directional punks then it's a case of boring yourself to death going to 3-2 counts and hoping they swing.

SDS

Your outfield is 3 RFs. I’d find someone who can play defense for center, and put walker in RF and Bryce / Stan in LF.

Of the two you mentioned, I’d say Rickey will help you more. Both of your 3B options are better than Matthews. I was disappointed with the card. His reaction makes his fielding bad, and his hitting never felt above what his lower diamond did for me.

Log in to reply