Biggio or sheffield

SDS

So i got 700k i eventually want to do the whole collection for mantle idk which side to do first i feel like the al collection is way more worth the money you get trout, wagner, biggio, and doolittle and it feels like the only card for the nl is sheffield opinions

SDS

I think what you’re thinking is correct. You can add 3-4 players to your roster immediately by doing the AL first. Biggio is very versatile, Trout is Trout, Wagner is very good and Doolittle is decent depending on your bullpen.

SDS

Agreed. For me, Biggio was the best surprise of the bunch. Hits for contact and has pop in his bat. Is incredibly fast on the base paths (90+). And he's a 2B with a secondary position at catcher (where he plays for me.)

SDS

@Serafim42-zaphod said in Biggio or sheffield:

Agreed. For me, Biggio was the best surprise of the bunch. Hits for contact and has pop in his bat. Is incredibly fast on the base paths (90+). And he's a 2B with a secondary position at catcher (where he plays for me.)

I got my boy sandberg at 2b hes the goat so id have biggio at catcher if i were to do it

SDS

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@Serafim42-zaphod said in Biggio or sheffield:

Agreed. For me, Biggio was the best surprise of the bunch. Hits for contact and has pop in his bat. Is incredibly fast on the base paths (90+). And he's a 2B with a secondary position at catcher (where he plays for me.)

I got my boy sandberg at 2b hes the goat so id have biggio at catcher if i were to do it

Same here. Sandberg is the best. Wasn't going to move him, so I benched my CAP catcher for Biggio.

SDS

@Serafim42-zaphod said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@Serafim42-zaphod said in Biggio or sheffield:

Agreed. For me, Biggio was the best surprise of the bunch. Hits for contact and has pop in his bat. Is incredibly fast on the base paths (90+). And he's a 2B with a secondary position at catcher (where he plays for me.)

I got my boy sandberg at 2b hes the goat so id have biggio at catcher if i were to do it

Same here. Sandberg is the best. Wasn't going to move him, so I benched my CAP catcher for Biggio.

The only thing i have about not doing the collection is i have the stubs to buy anyone that comes out if i want them and those cards that come out at the end of the year

SDS

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@Serafim42-zaphod said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@Serafim42-zaphod said in Biggio or sheffield:

Agreed. For me, Biggio was the best surprise of the bunch. Hits for contact and has pop in his bat. Is incredibly fast on the base paths (90+). And he's a 2B with a secondary position at catcher (where he plays for me.)

I got my boy sandberg at 2b hes the goat so id have biggio at catcher if i were to do it

Same here. Sandberg is the best. Wasn't going to move him, so I benched my CAP catcher for Biggio.

The only thing i have about not doing the collection is i have the stubs to buy anyone that comes out if i want them and those cards that come out at the end of the year

Also not a bad idea, but I will say this: you will NOT be disappointed with Mantle. He is by far the best hitter on my team. Switch hitter. Power. Speed. Fielding.
Even when I make bad swing he can hit them for doubles. Granted, I am not a great player, and I play mostly offline HOF/Veteran level games. But Mantle is hitting .440 for me.

SDS

@Mike__Honcho_361 said in Biggio or sheffield:

I think what you’re thinking is correct. You can add 3-4 players to your roster immediately by doing the AL first. Biggio is very versatile, Trout is Trout, Wagner is very good and Doolittle is decent depending on your bullpen.

I say it depends where the needs on your team are but I pretty much agree with this. I did the AL first and Biggio, Wagner, and Trout are still on my current team. Like mentioned Doolittle is also decent and I had him, along with Giambi, and Nolan Ryan on my team for a long time as well.

SDS

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@Mike__Honcho_361 said in Biggio or sheffield:

I think what you’re thinking is correct. You can add 3-4 players to your roster immediately by doing the AL first. Biggio is very versatile, Trout is Trout, Wagner is very good and Doolittle is decent depending on your bullpen.

I say it depends where the needs on your team are but I pretty much agree with this. I did the AL first and Biggio, Wagner, and Trout are still on my current team. Like mentioned Doolittle is also decent and I had him, along with Giambi, and Nolan Ryan on my team for a long time as well.
Im a Championship series play making a run for world series for a long time been close but not there yet my team is good my biggest weekness is my bullpen i have jackson babe and harper in the outfield if i get trout babe will go to first and rn i have 95 pablo at cather he rakes if i got biggio id out pablo at 3rd and then i have sandburg at 2b and my cap at ss and really good bench bats

SDS

This is tough im like 94% convinced to the AL collection haha

SDS

AL collection is better overall. Trout is gonna start for you, Wagner was a top LRP before the SS card, biggio can play C, 2B and CF in a pinch. He hits well better than his ratings suggest. I love Sheffield and have kept him in the lineup by moving him to 3rd after adding Ruth, but the other NL collection players are underwhelming.

SDS

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@Mike__Honcho_361 said in Biggio or sheffield:

I think what you’re thinking is correct. You can add 3-4 players to your roster immediately by doing the AL first. Biggio is very versatile, Trout is Trout, Wagner is very good and Doolittle is decent depending on your bullpen.

I say it depends where the needs on your team are but I pretty much agree with this. I did the AL first and Biggio, Wagner, and Trout are still on my current team. Like mentioned Doolittle is also decent and I had him, along with Giambi, and Nolan Ryan on my team for a long time as well.
Im a Championship series play making a run for world series for a long time been close but not there yet my team is good my biggest weekness is my bullpen i have jackson babe and harper in the outfield if i get trout babe will go to first and rn i have 95 pablo at cather he rakes if i got biggio id out pablo at 3rd and then i have sandburg at 2b and my cap at ss and really good bench bats

If your biggest weakness is your bullpen Wagner and Doolittle would probably help. I would say Wagner for sure would help and depending on who you have Doolittle might also. I actually love that Wagner card. He is still my closer! I also have Dibble but use either one depending on match ups. I have total confidence though whenever I go to that Wagner card to close out a game, he's filthy. Your D would be improved too by getting Babe out of the outfield and replacing him out there with Trout.

SDS

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@Mike__Honcho_361 said in Biggio or sheffield:

I think what you’re thinking is correct. You can add 3-4 players to your roster immediately by doing the AL first. Biggio is very versatile, Trout is Trout, Wagner is very good and Doolittle is decent depending on your bullpen.

I say it depends where the needs on your team are but I pretty much agree with this. I did the AL first and Biggio, Wagner, and Trout are still on my current team. Like mentioned Doolittle is also decent and I had him, along with Giambi, and Nolan Ryan on my team for a long time as well.
Im a Championship series play making a run for world series for a long time been close but not there yet my team is good my biggest weekness is my bullpen i have jackson babe and harper in the outfield if i get trout babe will go to first and rn i have 95 pablo at cather he rakes if i got biggio id out pablo at 3rd and then i have sandburg at 2b and my cap at ss and really good bench bats

If your biggest weakness is your bullpen Wagner and Doolittle would probably help. I would say Wagner for sure would help and depending on who you have Doolittle might also. I actually love that Wagner card. He is still my closer! I also have Dibble but use either one depending on match ups. I have total confidence though whenever I go to that Wagner card to close out a game, he's filthy. Your D would be improved too by getting Babe out of the outfield and replacing him out there with Trout.

My bullpen is osuna, alverado, rodney, gagne, hoffman and fingers i was fine with my bullpen till sds came out with that stupid startpitcher energy bs

SDS

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@Mike__Honcho_361 said in Biggio or sheffield:

I think what you’re thinking is correct. You can add 3-4 players to your roster immediately by doing the AL first. Biggio is very versatile, Trout is Trout, Wagner is very good and Doolittle is decent depending on your bullpen.

I say it depends where the needs on your team are but I pretty much agree with this. I did the AL first and Biggio, Wagner, and Trout are still on my current team. Like mentioned Doolittle is also decent and I had him, along with Giambi, and Nolan Ryan on my team for a long time as well.
Im a Championship series play making a run for world series for a long time been close but not there yet my team is good my biggest weekness is my bullpen i have jackson babe and harper in the outfield if i get trout babe will go to first and rn i have 95 pablo at cather he rakes if i got biggio id out pablo at 3rd and then i have sandburg at 2b and my cap at ss and really good bench bats

If your biggest weakness is your bullpen Wagner and Doolittle would probably help. I would say Wagner for sure would help and depending on who you have Doolittle might also. I actually love that Wagner card. He is still my closer! I also have Dibble but use either one depending on match ups. I have total confidence though whenever I go to that Wagner card to close out a game, he's filthy. Your D would be improved too by getting Babe out of the outfield and replacing him out there with Trout.

My bullpen is osuna, alverado, rodney, gagne, hoffman and fingers i was fine with my bullpen till sds came out with that stupid startpitcher energy bs

That's a pretty solid pen though. I have Gagne, Hoffman, and Fingers in my pen also. I had Rodney too up until I got Hoffman but Rodney isn't that bad either. I think you could definitely use Wagner though for sure. Maybe replace Osuna and Alverado with Wagner and Doolittle.

SDS

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@Mike__Honcho_361 said in Biggio or sheffield:

I think what you’re thinking is correct. You can add 3-4 players to your roster immediately by doing the AL first. Biggio is very versatile, Trout is Trout, Wagner is very good and Doolittle is decent depending on your bullpen.

I say it depends where the needs on your team are but I pretty much agree with this. I did the AL first and Biggio, Wagner, and Trout are still on my current team. Like mentioned Doolittle is also decent and I had him, along with Giambi, and Nolan Ryan on my team for a long time as well.
Im a Championship series play making a run for world series for a long time been close but not there yet my team is good my biggest weekness is my bullpen i have jackson babe and harper in the outfield if i get trout babe will go to first and rn i have 95 pablo at cather he rakes if i got biggio id out pablo at 3rd and then i have sandburg at 2b and my cap at ss and really good bench bats

If your biggest weakness is your bullpen Wagner and Doolittle would probably help. I would say Wagner for sure would help and depending on who you have Doolittle might also. I actually love that Wagner card. He is still my closer! I also have Dibble but use either one depending on match ups. I have total confidence though whenever I go to that Wagner card to close out a game, he's filthy. Your D would be improved too by getting Babe out of the outfield and replacing him out there with Trout.

My bullpen is osuna, alverado, rodney, gagne, hoffman and fingers i was fine with my bullpen till sds came out with that stupid startpitcher energy bs

That's a pretty solid pen though. I have Gagne, Hoffman, and Fingers in my pen also. I had Rodney too up until I got Hoffman but Rodney isn't that bad either. I think you could definitely use Wagner though for sure. Maybe replace Osuna and Alverado with Wagner and Doolittle.

Osuna is to good i have a 1.45 era with a .83 whip with 38 innings people cant hit him with me ok im doing the AL 100% convinced thanks guys

SDS

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@Mike__Honcho_361 said in Biggio or sheffield:

I think what you’re thinking is correct. You can add 3-4 players to your roster immediately by doing the AL first. Biggio is very versatile, Trout is Trout, Wagner is very good and Doolittle is decent depending on your bullpen.

I say it depends where the needs on your team are but I pretty much agree with this. I did the AL first and Biggio, Wagner, and Trout are still on my current team. Like mentioned Doolittle is also decent and I had him, along with Giambi, and Nolan Ryan on my team for a long time as well.
Im a Championship series play making a run for world series for a long time been close but not there yet my team is good my biggest weekness is my bullpen i have jackson babe and harper in the outfield if i get trout babe will go to first and rn i have 95 pablo at cather he rakes if i got biggio id out pablo at 3rd and then i have sandburg at 2b and my cap at ss and really good bench bats

If your biggest weakness is your bullpen Wagner and Doolittle would probably help. I would say Wagner for sure would help and depending on who you have Doolittle might also. I actually love that Wagner card. He is still my closer! I also have Dibble but use either one depending on match ups. I have total confidence though whenever I go to that Wagner card to close out a game, he's filthy. Your D would be improved too by getting Babe out of the outfield and replacing him out there with Trout.

My bullpen is osuna, alverado, rodney, gagne, hoffman and fingers i was fine with my bullpen till sds came out with that stupid startpitcher energy bs

That's a pretty solid pen though. I have Gagne, Hoffman, and Fingers in my pen also. I had Rodney too up until I got Hoffman but Rodney isn't that bad either. I think you could definitely use Wagner though for sure. Maybe replace Osuna and Alverado with Wagner and Doolittle.

Osuna is to good i have a 1.45 era with a .83 whip with 38 innings people cant hit him with me ok im doing the AL 100% convinced thanks guys

Yeah I know what you mean with Osuna. I didn't use it this year, but for the past couple of years early on in the game I've used his LS card and have had a lot of success with it too. Once you get Wagner and Doolittle just try them out and see how you do with them. I can pretty much guarantee that Wagner will do well. It's nice also to have an extra guy or two that you can rotate in and out of your bullpen with the stamina how it is and everything. Good luck man!

SDS

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@Mike__Honcho_361 said in Biggio or sheffield:

I think what you’re thinking is correct. You can add 3-4 players to your roster immediately by doing the AL first. Biggio is very versatile, Trout is Trout, Wagner is very good and Doolittle is decent depending on your bullpen.

I say it depends where the needs on your team are but I pretty much agree with this. I did the AL first and Biggio, Wagner, and Trout are still on my current team. Like mentioned Doolittle is also decent and I had him, along with Giambi, and Nolan Ryan on my team for a long time as well.
Im a Championship series play making a run for world series for a long time been close but not there yet my team is good my biggest weekness is my bullpen i have jackson babe and harper in the outfield if i get trout babe will go to first and rn i have 95 pablo at cather he rakes if i got biggio id out pablo at 3rd and then i have sandburg at 2b and my cap at ss and really good bench bats

If your biggest weakness is your bullpen Wagner and Doolittle would probably help. I would say Wagner for sure would help and depending on who you have Doolittle might also. I actually love that Wagner card. He is still my closer! I also have Dibble but use either one depending on match ups. I have total confidence though whenever I go to that Wagner card to close out a game, he's filthy. Your D would be improved too by getting Babe out of the outfield and replacing him out there with Trout.

My bullpen is osuna, alverado, rodney, gagne, hoffman and fingers i was fine with my bullpen till sds came out with that stupid startpitcher energy bs

That's a pretty solid pen though. I have Gagne, Hoffman, and Fingers in my pen also. I had Rodney too up until I got Hoffman but Rodney isn't that bad either. I think you could definitely use Wagner though for sure. Maybe replace Osuna and Alverado with Wagner and Doolittle.

Osuna is to good i have a 1.45 era with a .83 whip with 38 innings people cant hit him with me ok im doing the AL 100% convinced thanks guys

Yeah I know what you mean with Osuna. I didn't use it this year, but for the past couple of years early on in the game I've used his LS card and have had a lot of success with it too. Once you get Wagner and Doolittle just try them out and see how you do with them. I can pretty much guarantee that Wagner will do well. It's nice also to have an extra guy or two that you can rotate in and out of your bullpen with the stamina how it is and everything. Good luck man!

Thanks bro and you as well doing all the sell now orders now it hurts to see my stub count drop so low hahah been saving pretty much this whole year ive earned 1mil at least it so easy to get stubs this year

SDS

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@nG_Helix said in Biggio or sheffield:

@DeadPhish1976 said in Biggio or sheffield:

@Mike__Honcho_361 said in Biggio or sheffield:

I think what you’re thinking is correct. You can add 3-4 players to your roster immediately by doing the AL first. Biggio is very versatile, Trout is Trout, Wagner is very good and Doolittle is decent depending on your bullpen.

I say it depends where the needs on your team are but I pretty much agree with this. I did the AL first and Biggio, Wagner, and Trout are still on my current team. Like mentioned Doolittle is also decent and I had him, along with Giambi, and Nolan Ryan on my team for a long time as well.
Im a Championship series play making a run for world series for a long time been close but not there yet my team is good my biggest weekness is my bullpen i have jackson babe and harper in the outfield if i get trout babe will go to first and rn i have 95 pablo at cather he rakes if i got biggio id out pablo at 3rd and then i have sandburg at 2b and my cap at ss and really good bench bats

If your biggest weakness is your bullpen Wagner and Doolittle would probably help. I would say Wagner for sure would help and depending on who you have Doolittle might also. I actually love that Wagner card. He is still my closer! I also have Dibble but use either one depending on match ups. I have total confidence though whenever I go to that Wagner card to close out a game, he's filthy. Your D would be improved too by getting Babe out of the outfield and replacing him out there with Trout.

My bullpen is osuna, alverado, rodney, gagne, hoffman and fingers i was fine with my bullpen till sds came out with that stupid startpitcher energy bs

That's a pretty solid pen though. I have Gagne, Hoffman, and Fingers in my pen also. I had Rodney too up until I got Hoffman but Rodney isn't that bad either. I think you could definitely use Wagner though for sure. Maybe replace Osuna and Alverado with Wagner and Doolittle.

Osuna is to good i have a 1.45 era with a .83 whip with 38 innings people cant hit him with me ok im doing the AL 100% convinced thanks guys

Yeah I know what you mean with Osuna. I didn't use it this year, but for the past couple of years early on in the game I've used his LS card and have had a lot of success with it too. Once you get Wagner and Doolittle just try them out and see how you do with them. I can pretty much guarantee that Wagner will do well. It's nice also to have an extra guy or two that you can rotate in and out of your bullpen with the stamina how it is and everything. Good luck man!

Thanks bro and you as well doing all the sell now orders now it hurts to see my stub count drop so low hahah been saving pretty much this whole year ive earned 1mil at least it so easy to get stubs this year

For sure man, I hate seeing that stub count go down like that. Ive been saving for Trout and probably have enough to get him but its hard to pull the trigger. Its been a good year though to flip some cards and make stubs so no doubt you can get them back. The LS collection is definitely worth doing though. You get a lot of good cards along the way.

SDS

don't forget you get a decent amount of stubs back for doing the collections too

SDS

@Kerplop1 said in Biggio or sheffield:

don't forget you get a decent amount of stubs back for doing the collections too

Exactly. And good XP bonuses. I had like 400K in stubs and still needed the 8 most expensive LS players, Trout down thru Bellinger. But then I went through my collection, sold off duplicates, equipment and cards I didn’t really need (Topps Now, some Gold All Stars going for 15K), and I finished the LS collection with 100K to spare. Hello, Biggio, Sheffield and Mantle.

Log in to reply