Outfield / 1B Dilema. Any advice?

SDS

I grinded all weekend and got Babe! What a chore. I also recently took 99 Harper. I currently have Musial at 1st and love using him. Hitting for better average than anybody I use. Keep in mind I'm not great lol.

How would you position these players and who would you leave on the bench.

99 Harper / LF
Almost Prestiged Bellinger / CF
99 Walker / RF
Musial / 1B

Now have Ruth and have some stubs if I have obvious better choices. I sold 99 Robert last night. Loved his defense and speed, I just couldn't hit with him.

Thank you for the feedback.

SDS

Eric Thames

SDS

Isn't he only in the prestige choices? I'm just on level 15 diamond I think.

SDS

That’s tough man. Musial and Ruth are both defensive liabilities on defense. Because of that scenario I’d have to keep Walker, Cody and Bryce, Ruth at 1st and stash Musial on the bench. If you don’t care much about defense, Ruth in the outfield and Bryce on the bench with Musial at 1B

SDS

@bjd10048842 said in Outfield / 1B Dilema. Any advice?:

Eric Thames

How is this helpful in anyway to what op is asking?

SDS

Really comes down to who you like more from Harper and Musial, babe should play 1st but can get by in left putting Harper to the bench or on the market to use stubs on other areas, which then allows you to keep Musial at 1b.

SDS

@Brock27870 said in Outfield / 1B Dilema. Any advice?:

I grinded all weekend and got Babe! What a chore. I also recently took 99 Harper. I currently have Musial at 1st and love using him. Hitting for better average than anybody I use. Keep in mind I'm not great lol.

How would you position these players and who would you leave on the bench.

99 Harper / LF
Almost Prestiged Bellinger / CF
99 Walker / RF
Musial / 1B

Now have Ruth and have some stubs if I have obvious better choices. I sold 99 Robert last night. Loved his defense and speed, I just couldn't hit with him.

Thank you for the feedback.

[censored] man Robert is legit my best player. I would bench Belli honestly. I just got Babe as well and he pushed my FAVORITE player of all time to the bench, Frank Thomas.

SDS

Can you sell Harper? Diamond D on Walker in RF and Belli in CF (when prestiged) makes Harper the odd man out as far as I'm concerned. Babe should be serviceable in left with Bellinger's help and then you can keep Stan at 1. Otherwise there are just too many lefty Bats, and too many holes to try and fill.

SDS

@lazy_toast said in Outfield / 1B Dilema. Any advice?:

@Brock27870 said in Outfield / 1B Dilema. Any advice?:

I grinded all weekend and got Babe! What a chore. I also recently took 99 Harper. I currently have Musial at 1st and love using him. Hitting for better average than anybody I use. Keep in mind I'm not great lol.

How would you position these players and who would you leave on the bench.

99 Harper / LF
Almost Prestiged Bellinger / CF
99 Walker / RF
Musial / 1B

Now have Ruth and have some stubs if I have obvious better choices. I sold 99 Robert last night. Loved his defense and speed, I just couldn't hit with him.

Thank you for the feedback.

[censored] man Robert is legit my best player. I would bench Belli honestly. I just got Babe as well and he pushed my FAVORITE player of all time to the bench, Frank Thomas.

Robert might be the best player I have used all year. I just planned on trying him out and I can't bring myself to sell him.

SDS

@Brock27870 said in Outfield / 1B Dilema. Any advice?:

I grinded all weekend and got Babe! What a chore. I also recently took 99 Harper. I currently have Musial at 1st and love using him. Hitting for better average than anybody I use. Keep in mind I'm not great lol.

How would you position these players and who would you leave on the bench.

99 Harper / LF
Almost Prestiged Bellinger / CF
99 Walker / RF
Musial / 1B

Now have Ruth and have some stubs if I have obvious better choices. I sold 99 Robert last night. Loved his defense and speed, I just couldn't hit with him.

Thank you for the feedback.

My first question is do you struggle to hit with any of these guys (maybe one more than others if there are multiple?).

Walker imo is a lock. I'd think you can put Harper in RF, Belli in CF and Walker in LF and be ok since walker and Belli have high enough defense ratings to work out of position.

I'd then put Babe at first and bench Musial.

Now if you're really good with Musial, I think he needs to stay at first due to low defense rating and then you got to figure out the OF situation in which I think its really down to either Belli or Harper being benched.

Personally Walker is too good to ever take out imo and I dont think I'd bench Babe after all the work I would have to do to get him (unless you absolutely terrible with him).

SDS

Since you mash with Musial, I'd leave him at first, put Ruth in LF, and sell Harper and use the stubs to upgrade at another position or pitcher.

SDS

Ji Man Choi

SDS

@James97M said in Outfield / 1B Dilema. Any advice?:

@bjd10048842 said in Outfield / 1B Dilema. Any advice?:

Eric Thames

How is this helpful in anyway to what op is asking?

Who said it was supposed to be helpful? 99% of the responses I get to legitimate questions aren't helpful. Now I'm contributing the unhelpfullness.

SDS

Keep the outfield then you could alternate games with Stan or Babe at first. See who you hit best with and use the other as your power lefty bench bat.

Log in to reply