Who to bench for Cobb?

SDS

Right now I have Mantle in left, MVP Trout in center, and Walker in right. Am I crazy for thinking I'm going to have to bench Trout for Cobb? That card looks insane and I'm going to have to find a place for him. I feel like I can get base his lackluster arm when he has high level speed and fielding/reaction.

SDS

Depends on how your lineup goes as far as L/R go. But with the release of Kershaw I’m taking walker out personally

SDS

make two different teams to keep it fresh ... especially when Mays and Griffey also drop

SDS

Play whomever u hit best with or whatever line up looks more balanced! Personally for me I wouldn't bench trout! So its either u bench mantle or walker! I would go trout LF. Cobb CF. Walker RF. Have mantle as late game big bat off bench! Switch hitters are perfect late in game!!

SDS

If you need a leadoff hitter, bench Walker for Cobb and put Cobb in LF with his weak arm. If you don't need a leadoff hitter, keep your outfield as it is.

SDS

Or look at it like this who can u sell? Mantle and trout u can't!! Sell walker! Hes worth almost 200k to !!

SDS

I’ll also add that in taking Walker out because I hit the worst with him out of the 3 too. Don’t feel obligated to play Trout or Mantle because you locked all of those stubs in. It’s meaningless in a few months anyway

SDS

@the_dragon1912 said in Who to bench for Cobb?:

I’ll also add that in taking Walker out because I hit the worst with him out of the 3 too. Don’t feel obligated to play Trout or Mantle because you locked all of those stubs in. It’s meaningless in a few months anyway

September, October, November, December, January, February, March.

That's more than a few months 🙂

SDS

This is all good stuff. I need another to balance out my lineup and i actually hit worse with Trout out of the three. Also, I locked in Walker because I collected all of the bosses for his program.

I won't get Cobb immediately, so I'll see what my lineup looks like in a few weeks when it does happen. Either way I know it is a good problem to have!

SDS

cobb is an ideal ph/pr. defence is good but arm is bad. Gonna stick with PTrout PMantle PWalker.

SDS

What are people seeing with Cobb that I'm not?

Log in to reply