Who is your outfield if you have every card?

SDS

Mantle is never leaving CF. Have Walker in RF and Trout in Lf.

I love the fielding and speed that gives but ....
Ted Williams bat, Ty Cobb bat , and Ruth make me wanna change.

Opinions on sacrificing defense for those bats. I have Musial at first. Suffice it to say, I have every card for all the positions. So I’m not lacking quality bats elsewhere

SDS

Trout Mantle Cobb.

SDS

Cobb-Mantle-Walker.

SDS

All very good but how about if you stick to primary positions? So who’s the best LF?

SDS

@maccanix said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

All very good but how about if you stick to primary positions? So who’s the best LF?

If you only do primary positions then Lou Brock is the best LF. Only one close is Rickey Henderson and he isn’t nearly good enough for his price tag

SDS

@maccanix said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

All very good but how about if you stick to primary positions? So who’s the best LF?

Why would you even do this?

SDS

@the_dragon1912 said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

@maccanix said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

All very good but how about if you stick to primary positions? So who’s the best LF?

If you only do primary positions then Lou Brock is the best LF. Only one close is Rickey Henderson and he isn’t nearly good enough for his price tag

Ted Williams says hi. Probably the best hitter in the game.

SDS

@Ikasnu said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

Trout Mantle Cobb.

You abandoned your very good friend walker?!

SDS

I’m a huge ted Williams fan so he’ll never leave my lineup. So I’d go with Williams, Cobb and Mantle. Once Griffey is out, Williams, Griffey, Mantle.

SDS

Prestige versions of Trout, Mantle, and Bellinger. You can't convince me Walker is better than Belli.

Eventually 99 Griffey will likely take over in right for Bellinger. I hated Mays last year so his card is/will be irrelevant to me. Cobb is the best 5th bench bat/speed option if you build your bench 2 lefty, 2 righty, and a pinch runner.

SDS

@olivegarden2 said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

@Ikasnu said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

Trout Mantle Cobb.

You abandoned your very good friend walker?!

Bench bat now.

SDS

I hit really well with Mantle and Trout, I never used Walker, however he’s done much damage to me. I will try Cobb, Mays and Griffey will eventually join the group.

SDS

@Ikasnu said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

@olivegarden2 said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

@Ikasnu said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

Trout Mantle Cobb.

You abandoned your very good friend walker?!

Bench bat now.

Noooo...any Rockies left on your team? I sometimes bench Dwight Evans and have 99 sale who kinda counts...

SDS

Waiting for Belli to replace Walker.

SDS

@olivegarden2 said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

@Ikasnu said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

@olivegarden2 said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

@Ikasnu said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

Trout Mantle Cobb.

You abandoned your very good friend walker?!

Bench bat now.

Noooo...any Rockies left on your team? I sometimes bench Dwight Evans and have 99 sale who kinda counts...

Story

SDS

Rickey Mickey n Vladdy

SDS

Trout mantle and walker cobb could make my team tho

SDS

Walker, Mantle, Musial, but Cobb might replace Musial due to his speed if I decide to get him. Musial is one of my best hitters though. Belli gets honorable mention.

SDS

@CalisGW said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

Mantle is never leaving CF. Have Walker in RF and Trout in Lf.

I love the fielding and speed that gives but ....
Ted Williams bat, Ty Cobb bat , and Ruth make me wanna change.

Opinions on sacrificing defense for those bats. I have Musial at first. Suffice it to say, I have every card for all the positions. So I’m not lacking quality bats elsewhere

For some reason Walker is the 2nd best hitter in the game, after Mantle, so for me that only leaves one other position up for grabs until a 99 Griffey Jr.

SDS

@CalisGW said in Who is your outfield if you have every card?:

Mantle is never leaving CF. Have Walker in RF and Trout in Lf.

I love the fielding and speed that gives but ....
Ted Williams bat, Ty Cobb bat , and Ruth make me wanna change.

Opinions on sacrificing defense for those bats. I have Musial at first. Suffice it to say, I have every card for all the positions. So I’m not lacking quality bats elsewhere

As embarrassing as this is for me to admit, I simply can’t hit with the Mick. Idk if it’s his stance that weirds me out or what. I hit better with Blackmon than probly any other card I’ve ever used! I know it’s in my head, but there’s nothing I can do about it. Time for me to move on.

Log in to reply