Which Catcher (no created ) if have access to all of them

SDS

I kind of want to use Piazza because i am a Mets fan and that power and contact. I hit with him about the same as anyone else( which is bad).

That Ivan defense though looks great and offense looks a little bit more respectable if Prestige.

There is Biggio for speed, but that defense. is only ok.

So who would you use?

SDS

Of those three, Pudge for sure. Catcher defense and arm matters this year, and Piazza doesn't have much of either.

SDS

I would love to say Piazza but im gonna say Posada for now. Haven't had the chance to use the new Pudge card but he looks great too.

SDS

This is just my preference but I love Yadi. You might say b-but no 80 power. It's still good

SDS

Best offensive imo is Posada (Piazza 2nd, horrible swing)
Best defense is Wieters/Posey
Best all around is Biggio

SDS

I started using the FS Bart, and he may find a way to becoming my new player behind the plate.

If he starts faltering, I'll go back to one of the switch-hitting monsters - Posada, Weiters, or Panda. They're all very good.

SDS

When Adley comes out, use him. Biggio until then.

SDS

Posada, i dont hit well with Biggio, Posey only vs LHP. Posada has good swing and decent defense. But to me it is going to be CAP all year, as usual.

SDS

Pudge for right now, he shuts down the running game.

SDS

@SpudXpert27 said in Which Catcher (no created ) if have access to all of them:

This is just my preference but I love Yadi. You might say b-but no 80 power. It's still good

Yadi is a beast, quick swing and high exit velos. On top of that, diamond defense with 90+ arm.

SDS

Good ol Joey Bart for me.

SDS

This new Sean Murphy is a goat!! Hitting good and he’s yet to let anyone steal 2nd and Ol Mickey tried a couple times last game

SDS

Grandal, all day every day. Any version crushes fastballs. You'll thank me later.

SDS

I’ll be using pudge. Have been using Biggio

SDS

That Awards Molina is really really good

SDS

@CalisGW said in Which Catcher (no created ) if have access to all of them:

I kind of want to use Piazza because i am a Mets fan and that power and contact. I hit with him about the same as anyone else( which is bad).

That Ivan defense though looks great and offense looks a little bit more respectable if Prestige.

There is Biggio for speed, but that defense. is only ok.

So who would you use?

I find piazza has a very slow swing. I’d try 99 posey or prestige posey.

SDS

@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Which Catcher (no created ) if have access to all of them:

When Adley comes out, use him. Biggio until then.

He will be the

SDS

@mrwonderful95 said in Which Catcher (no created ) if have access to all of them:

@CalisGW said in Which Catcher (no created ) if have access to all of them:

I kind of want to use Piazza because i am a Mets fan and that power and contact. I hit with him about the same as anyone else( which is bad).

That Ivan defense though looks great and offense looks a little bit more respectable if Prestige.

There is Biggio for speed, but that defense. is only ok.

So who would you use?

I find piazza has a very slow swing. I’d try 99 posey or prestige posey.

I have prestige Posey, Cant hit with him either . Seems i need the high high contact players to be able to do anything remotely decent online.

I wont lie, that arm on Ivan is [censored] nice.

SDS

None of them honestly. You said you hit bad with Piazza so why even bother? To me Pudge wasn’t good last year and this year wouldn’t be much difference. His discipline and no check swing trait turns me off. Only catcher I’ve been able to keep above .300 for an extended time is Kendall. It sucks but I’m using who I do good with.

SDS

I use grandal

Log in to reply