Should be able to see opponents PCI

SDS

Why is this not a thing? I feel like SDS hates transparency, makes no sense why only the offense can see the result of a hit...

SDS

Why should you know where we are focusing our pci at? would give to much info to the pitcher. You crazy.

SDS

@CalisGW said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

Why should you know where we are focusing our pci at? would give to much info to the pitcher. You crazy.

I mean after the hit already occurred, I'm just referring to feedback

SDS

@GOtexas1 said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

@CalisGW said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

Why should you know where we are focusing our pci at? would give to much info to the pitcher. You crazy.

I mean after the hit already occurred, I'm just referring to feedback

I know what you meant, a pitcher should not know where we are sitting at. if it shows we missed underneath ball or we missed over. It lets you know if we were sitting high or low. Baseball pitchers do not get that info in a game, why should you?

SDS

Not during a game you shouldnt. That would be highly unrealistic. You can already see the batters swing, just like real pitchers can. That should be enough. Probably too much already automatically getting timing feedback. We should have to judge all that for ourselves. It isnt that hard.

SDS

Definitely understand your argument, however, it would be good if there were some way to understand how well your opponent squared up a ball and the result of that. Maybe not in real-time, but if I get a poorly hit home run or vice-versa, that should be made transparent before the game ends

SDS

@GOtexas1 said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

Definitely understand your argument, however, it would be good if there were some way to understand how well your opponent squared up a ball and the result of that. Maybe not in real-time, but if I get a poorly hit home run or vice-versa, that should be made transparent before the game ends

There is, you can look at your opponents hit-ratings in the game analysis thing, it usually labels it from like 1-15, which tells you how well it was squared up.

SDS

OP just wants his hand held, typical attitude on this forum.

SDS

@CalisGW said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

Why should you know where we are focusing our pci at? would give to much info to the pitcher. You crazy.

How could someone know if you're sitting in that spot? For all I know, you could have moved the PCI into the area.

SDS

@Matt_42187 said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

@CalisGW said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

Why should you know where we are focusing our pci at? would give to much info to the pitcher. You crazy.

How could someone know if you're sitting in that spot? For all I know, you could have moved the PCI into the area.

Timing indicator. If we are late with swing and under the ball.. we were sitting low/ If we were late and swing over top of ball..means we were sitting high. Vice versa for early swings.

SDS

It would be much too embarrassing sometimes.

SDS

@CalisGW said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

@Matt_42187 said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

@CalisGW said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

Why should you know where we are focusing our pci at? would give to much info to the pitcher. You crazy.

How could someone know if you're sitting in that spot? For all I know, you could have moved the PCI into the area.

Timing indicator. If we are late with swing and under the ball.. we were sitting low/ If we were late and swing over top of ball..means we were sitting high. Vice versa for early swings.

That still doesn’t tell me if they are sitting on a pitch before it’s thrown. They could just be bad at PCI placement. It happens to me every game.

SDS

@Matt_42187 said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

@CalisGW said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

@Matt_42187 said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

@CalisGW said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

Why should you know where we are focusing our pci at? would give to much info to the pitcher. You crazy.

How could someone know if you're sitting in that spot? For all I know, you could have moved the PCI into the area.

Timing indicator. If we are late with swing and under the ball.. we were sitting low/ If we were late and swing over top of ball..means we were sitting high. Vice versa for early swings.

That still doesn’t tell me if they are sitting on a pitch before it’s thrown. They could just be bad at PCI placement. It happens to me every game.

I mean really, how much hand holding do you want? Based on what pitch was thrown. Speed of pitch and location of pitch. Then add timing and where our PCI ended. You can deduce where we were sitting our PCI and what kind of pitch we were looking for.

SDS

SDS knows better than to enduce that much rage.

SDS

@CalisGW said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

@Matt_42187 said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

@CalisGW said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

@Matt_42187 said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

@CalisGW said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

Why should you know where we are focusing our pci at? would give to much info to the pitcher. You crazy.

How could someone know if you're sitting in that spot? For all I know, you could have moved the PCI into the area.

Timing indicator. If we are late with swing and under the ball.. we were sitting low/ If we were late and swing over top of ball..means we were sitting high. Vice versa for early swings.

That still doesn’t tell me if they are sitting on a pitch before it’s thrown. They could just be bad at PCI placement. It happens to me every game.

I mean really, how much hand holding do you want? Based on what pitch was thrown. Speed of pitch and location of pitch. Then add timing and where our PCI ended. You can deduce where we were sitting our PCI and what kind of pitch we were looking for.

I don’t care about pci showing. I was helping out the OP. But anyways, someone could be sitting on a completely different pitch and location on the next swing. So really, it doesn’t matter if the PCI shows on feedback because it can change pitch to pitch.

SDS

This is the worst suggestion I have seen on here in ages. You cannot read someone's mind in real life, why should you be able to in the game and exploit their patterns and habits? Awful idea, with all due respect.

SDS

@tfrog76 said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

This is the worst suggestion I have seen on here in ages. You cannot read someone's mind in real life, why should you be able to in the game and exploit their patterns and habits? Awful idea, with all due respect.

Showing the opponents feedback swing is pretty close to exploiting their habits.

SDS

@Matt_42187 said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

@tfrog76 said in Should be able to see opponents PCI:

This is the worst suggestion I have seen on here in ages. You cannot read someone's mind in real life, why should you be able to in the game and exploit their patterns and habits? Awful idea, with all due respect.

Showing the opponents feedback swing is pretty close to exploiting their habits.

A lot of things in this game don't mirror real life.

SDS

I thought that opponent's PCI showed up for online pitchers in MLBTS 15 and 16, if I remember correctly.

Log in to reply