2B/3B/SA/C Positioning advice with Tatis?

SDS

Just unlocked Tatis and looking for some advice about lineup and defensive positions now that i've got most guys in the squad - a few different variations I could go with:

SS Rollins/CAP
CF Trout
LF Prestige Mantle
1B Babe/Musial/Papi
2B Tatis/Cano
RF Walker
3B Sheffield
C Posada/Biggio/Pudge/CAP

I really want to get Tatis in there - but unsure whether to replace Sheffield at 3B or Cano at 2B. Cano has been amazing for me, but Sheffield has been just as good.

I hit for better avg. with Biggio at C - more power with Posada obviously but can't seem to get it going with Posada so far. Having Biggio at C gives me a pretty RHH heavy lineup and honestly I hit better with LHH and SH. Also have catcher CAP that I can use.

Tatis has way better fielding than Sheffield at 3B, but I'm losing that bat if I replace too.
Anyone have any thoughts?

SDS

Create a CAP at catcher, play Tatais to SS, and keep Cano at second?

SDS

@SevisonJN said in 2B/3B/SA/C Positioning advice with Tatis?:

Create a CAP at catcher, play Tatais to SS, and keep Cano at second?

Sorry should have mentioned I also have a CAP C that I can use. Close to prestiging Biggio but CAP the better option here you think?

SDS

Tatis at short and CAP at 2? Won't take any more than 15 games and he's the 89 Diamond again.

SDS

Defense wise, put Mantle in CF. Trout in LF . Trout can handle the secondary position penalty better. Put Tatis at 3rd. That arm and defense at 3rd is just tooooo good. Hornsby at 2nd if you can afford him over Cano

SDS

@EvylShaun said in 2B/3B/SA/C Positioning advice with Tatis?:

Tatis at short and CAP at 2? Won't take any more than 15 games and he's the 89 Diamond again.

I thought about this but not sure if I can be bothered with the grind again tbh with all the great options out there. Definitely a possibility though thanks!

SDS

@CalisGW said in 2B/3B/SA/C Positioning advice with Tatis?:

Defense wise, put Mantle in CF. Trout in LF . Trout can handle the secondary position penalty better. Put Tatis at 3rd. That arm and defense at 3rd is just tooooo good. Hornsby at 2nd if you can afford him over Cano

Thanks for the tip! I’ve been flip flopping those 2 for a while trying to find the best combo But hadn’t quite settled yet. I was leaning towards Tatis at 3b because of how well I hit with Cano, so that lines up with what I was thinking. Thanks for the thoughts!

SDS

@CalisGW said in 2B/3B/SA/C Positioning advice with Tatis?:

Defense wise, put Mantle in CF. Trout in LF . Trout can handle the secondary position penalty better. Put Tatis at 3rd. That arm and defense at 3rd is just tooooo good. Hornsby at 2nd if you can afford him over Cano

Lol

SDS

Trout lf
Mantle cf
Babe 1b
Hornsby 2b
Tatis ss
Cap c
Walker rf
Chipper or Sheffield 3b

Log in to reply