Gehrig worth it?

SDS

I know ruth has better stats, and i know people will say he’s better just because of that or because they don’t want to do the extreme stuff, but what is the general consensus on lou? Is he worth it? I’m not putting one of those slow pokes in the outfield, and i’m generally reticent to play someone with worse stats. I also have not been able to hit a lick with ruth, but don’t let that influence your answer. Is his swing really golden?

SDS

I think Gehrig is better than Ruth because of his swing. He is also 6ft which is a sweet spot for the strike zone in my opinion.

SDS

@marcopiol said in Gehrig worth it?:

I know ruth has better stats, and i know people will say he’s better just because of that or because they don’t want to do the extreme stuff, but what is the general consensus on lou? Is he worth it? I’m not putting one of those slow pokes in the outfield, and i’m generally reticent to play someone with worse stats. I also have not been able to hit a lick with ruth, but don’t let that influence your answer. Is his swing really golden?

I can’t take Ruth out so it doesn’t matter...

SDS

you say you cant hit with babe? then try stan, frank, brett, thome, or if you dont have interest try. them in conquest and grind for lou and see who you likle or not. No reason you cant play conquest and get pearson and see if you. find someone you like. afteer. all that you still want. lou imo is = to babe or stan, then ok do showdown. if you do that then all you got is 2 extremely irritiating moments that may take 15 seconds or 15 days. id slowly grind towards. him and look for other options, if none to be found then ok go for it. I have him but dont feel like I needed

SDS

So I just got Gehrig, and I'm proud to put him in the lineup for the grind it was to get him. To be honest though, I don't think you're getting THAT much more than Ruth or even Musial. After prestige he is even better a great combination of defense, contact, power and even speed for a first basemen. Then, if you have the skill, or the stubs, Pujols will probably be better.

Log in to reply