Ok SDS... Perfect-Perfect needs to be fixed.

SDS

Alright people, I KNOW for fact that it isn't just a me thing, Perfect-Perfect outs need to be NON-EXISTENT. PERIOD. No ifs, ands, or buts about it. If you hit a perfect-perfect flyball WITH 125 POWER it should be a no-doubt homer EVERY time. No matter what. Any don't even get me started with the perfect-perfect lineouts. I know, perfect-perfect liner is more straight, not much launch angle, but still, THEY SHOULD NOT BE CAUGHT. Perfect-Perfect Grounders make sense for getting caught, since you are hitting it on the ground. But the other two, this is unacceptable. I hope I am not the only one who thinks this should be fixed.

@sds I would really appreciate it if you could take note of this, or at least fix Perfect-Perfect Flyball. Just that change alone would make everyone SO much happier with the game. Thanks.

What do you all think? Do you agree with me? What do you hate the MOST about Perfect-Perfect Outs?

SDS

@DestroyingFlame said in Ok SDS... Perfect-Perfect needs to be fixed.:

but still, THEY SHOULD NOT BE CAUGHT.

Ummm, and if they are hit to someone? then what? A perfect grounder should be harder to field than a liner. I could still go shag 105mph liners today, but dont put in front of a hard hit grounder. I will move.

Let me clarify, 105-110 mph off the bat I will shag. Because then it is much less when it gets to you.

SDS

@DestroyingFlame said in Ok SDS... Perfect-Perfect needs to be fixed.:

Alright people, I KNOW for fact that it isn't just a me thing, Perfect-Perfect outs need to be NON-EXISTENT. PERIOD. No ifs, ands, or buts about it. If you hit a perfect-perfect flyball WITH 125 POWER it should be a no-doubt homer EVERY time. No matter what. Any don't even get me started with the perfect-perfect lineouts. I know, perfect-perfect liner is more straight, not much launch angle, but still, THEY SHOULD NOT BE CAUGHT. Perfect-Perfect Grounders make sense for getting caught, since you are hitting it on the ground. But the other two, this is unacceptable. I hope I am not the only one who thinks this should be fixed.

@sds I would really appreciate it if you could take note of this, or at least fix Perfect-Perfect Flyball. Just that change alone would make everyone SO much happier with the game. Thanks.

What do you all think? Do you agree with me? What do you hate the MOST about Perfect-Perfect Outs?

Perfect-Perfect outs need to be nonexistent he says, no matter what. He then proceeds to say perfect groundouts are ok. alright buddy

SDS

@SpudXpert27
I apologize. I did not clarify enough. I meant perfect-perfect flyballs and liners.

@ChuckCLC
Good point. If they go straight to someone, that, in my opinion, is the ONLY time they should be caught. I do agree with that.

SDS

They need to fix pitching

SDS

Well, i don't agree with perfect perfect line drives being guaranteed hits, as far as perfect perfect fly balls I think if the batter is at a certain power threshold it should be a homer taking into account wind, elevation, and stadium dimensions, it should be a homer. I had a perfect perfect flyball to center get caught not even at the warning track, hit by Walker against a righty. That probably shouldn't happen. but otherwise no matter how good contact good contact is it shouldn't guarantee a hit.

SDS

@Hubijerk said in Ok SDS... Perfect-Perfect needs to be fixed.:

Well, i don't agree with perfect perfect line drives being guaranteed hits, as far as perfect perfect fly balls I think if the batter is at a certain power threshold it should be a homer taking into account wind, elevation, and stadium dimensions, it should be a homer. I had a perfect perfect flyball to center get caught not even at the warning track, hit by Walker against a righty. That probably shouldn't happen. but otherwise no matter how good contact good contact is it shouldn't guarantee a hit.

100% agree, this is how it should be. They can’t take us seriously expecting things like the OP. I’ll just add on that PP also should NEVER go foul. That seems to happen more now than the rarity it was at the beginning of the year. I’ve got 7-10 screenshots of this happening since they dropped the extreme program.

SDS

@MrGamebred said in Ok SDS... Perfect-Perfect needs to be fixed.:

@Hubijerk said in Ok SDS... Perfect-Perfect needs to be fixed.:

Well, i don't agree with perfect perfect line drives being guaranteed hits, as far as perfect perfect fly balls I think if the batter is at a certain power threshold it should be a homer taking into account wind, elevation, and stadium dimensions, it should be a homer. I had a perfect perfect flyball to center get caught not even at the warning track, hit by Walker against a righty. That probably shouldn't happen. but otherwise no matter how good contact good contact is it shouldn't guarantee a hit.

100% agree, this is how it should be. They can’t take us seriously expecting things like the OP. I’ll just add on that PP also should NEVER go foul. That seems to happen more now than the rarity it was at the beginning of the year. I’ve got 7-10 screenshots of this happening since they dropped the extreme program.

Also agree with this. I had Tatis Jr. flyout to CF off Pearson. Perfect Perfect Flyball with 125 power vs righties!

SDS

Perfect-perfect's are fine... It's the timing on "goods" and "early" hits

SDS

Ok when yellich hits a perfect perfect off a righty and it barely makes the warning track, but tony gywnn with 65 power hits a good good no doubter, it’s bs

SDS

You do realize that if they did this that good players would be batting like .500-.600. Getting one or two every 9 inning game I’d understand you being mad but if you get 7-10 a game You’re being rewarded. I’d bet my average is over .650 still on perfect perfects, when I kept track.

SDS

Sds need fix gameplay but thay sux changed hitting after 3 days and never fix it

SDS

My last game log, perfect-perfect flyout with Sheffield against a lefty (124 power) at Rogers Center.

Maybe Rogers Center has a secret?

SDS

I can see it now. MLB The Show 21. @SDS why is every perfect/perfect a HR? Or a base hit? Just because a guy hits the ball spot on doesn't mean it's always a hit. I'm going back to The Show 20.

SDS

@GOtexas1 said in Ok SDS... Perfect-Perfect needs to be fixed.:

My last game log, perfect-perfect flyout with Sheffield against a lefty (124 power) at Rogers Center.

Maybe Rogers Center has a secret?

Now that I think about it... Rogers is where I hit PP to center with walker that didn't even reach the track....

SDS

Game plays like hot garbage when every perfect swing is an XBH or HR. If they made it harder to get perfect fair enough, but when they rewarded good swings at a high rate earlier in the year, I got sick and tired of playing games with 50 combined hits and 35 combined runs. “Oh and could it be? Back to back to back to back to back home runs!” Nah, I’m good thanks. I don’t want to sit there for months while my opponent hits endless home runs and congratulates himself on getting rewarded at a decent rate. That’s worse than perfect line outs any day of the week, it makes me sick tbh.

SDS

A perfect perfect liner should not be caught? Lol. So, if you hit a perfect perfect liner right at a diamond left fielder in the game he should just move out of the way? Or let it hit his face? Cause its a perfect perfect liner? Lmao. This game is seriously just a hr derby already, can't always get a prize in life young man

SDS

Well IRL this year I believe it was Stanton who hit a 117mph liner that was an out. Sooooooo yeah.

SDS

There are plenty of perfectly hit baseballs in the MLB that go for outs, especially liners. I also get frustrated when a P-P ends up being an out, but generally speaking I end up catching an equal amount of breaks on the other side that makes it all even out. Plus one or two swings shouldn’t be the end all be all in the game anyway.

SDS

@MHHW33 said in Ok SDS... Perfect-Perfect needs to be fixed.:

You do realize that if they did this that good players would be batting like .500-.600. Getting one or two every 9 inning game I’d understand you being mad but if you get 7-10 a game You’re being rewarded. I’d bet my average is over .650 still on perfect perfects, when I kept track.

I personally would love this! If we're playing online against other humans, we should be rewarded for skill. If you, me, or anyone playing the game can get perfect timing, perfect contact constantly, they should be rewarded by hitting .600+ and scoring tons of runs. That shows their incredible skill. At the same time, pitching should work the same way. Perfect input should put the pitch right where it was aimed.

Before someone asks, well what happens if both people execute perfectly, who's input is more important? The obvious answer is the hitter. Pitchers make perfect pitches IRL that get smashed because hitters make perfect contact. It doesn't mean there are never line outs on those hits or scorched ground outs, but the perfectly hit fly balls by almost any MLB hitter with decent pop leaves the ball park these days.

The real solution is to make the PCI smaller and actually matter. If the PCI is not on the ball, it should be a swing and miss EVERY SINGLE TIME. If that happened hitting would change drastically. It would eliminate people fouling off tons of pitches that are nowhere near the zone. Sorry for the long post.

Log in to reply