Ty Cobb or Prestige Eric davis?

SDS

any thoughts on who i should get? i already have davis and could lock for prestige or sell and get cobb. Stubs are not the issue i just dont like spending them. I cant use both so what do you guys think? cobb better overall but weak arm and less power

SDS

I love ED and have had him prestiged for a while but Cobb is the play here, don't worry too much about the arm.

SDS

Arm is the least important OF attribute. You want guys with speed and above average reaction. I've enjoyed Cobb, but I still prefer Prestige Brock in LF.

SDS

Cobb may look like he has no power on paper but he hits tanks on a regular basis. Play him in Left and don't look back.

SDS

Prestige Brock is a GOAT!!

SDS

@TEXAS10PT said in Ty Cobb or Prestige Eric davis?:

Cobb may look like he has no power on paper but he hits tanks on a regular basis. Play him in Left and don't look back.

90 power both sides is a TON of power. We've just gotten accustomed to these 120+ guys. Remember, the original threshold was 80, I believe that's still the case.

SDS

What a tough choice. I love Eric Davis's card so much this year, but Cobb is great too.

SDS

Cobb is a game changer batting lead off. I’ve had guys pitch out when he’s on base and he still beats the throw easily. In the outfield his quick feet make up for his throwing.

SDS

Cobb is cheeks. Go Davis.

SDS
This post is deleted!
SDS
This post is deleted!
SDS

I am just gonna get Trout instead actually. All I need now is HRD cards which hopefully drop soon because of new conquest

SDS

Eric Davis was one of my faves, both with the Reds and the Orioles, and Cobb was a well-known richard, but Cobb > Davis, hands down.

Log in to reply