Alright, its tier list time, all input needed/wanted.

SDS

So its time to do a TSN tier list. My goal with this list is to provide data from the users here, what's preferred and potentially help some people who are in a quandary wanting this same information, who's the best and why.

So here is how its going to go, in several weeks I am going to be creating multiple topics, 10 total for each position based on the replies to this topic. Primary positions only. You don't have to fill every position if you don't want to.

Im going with a point system, I want everyone to list 5 players at each position, I'll create my own input below in a post and a template at the bottom of this post. #1 on the list receives 5 points, #5 receives 1 point, add up at the end and create the final list.

Feel free to contribute to 1 position or all 10. Here's the template

Starting Pitcher
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Relief Pitcher
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Catcher
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

First Basemen
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Second Basemen
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Third Basemen
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Shortstop
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Left Field
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Centerfield
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Right Field
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Go!

SDS

Starting Pitcher

  1. Max Sherzer
  2. Tom Seaver
  3. Corbin Burnes (TN)
  4. Chris Sale
  5. Blake Snell (PL)

Relief Pitcher

  1. Gagne
  2. Chapman
  3. Fingers
  4. Dibble
  5. Nenn

Catcher

  1. Posada
  2. Posey

First Basemen

  1. Gherig
  2. Bellinger (PotM)
  3. Ortiz
  4. Thome
  5. Mcovey

Second Basemen

  1. Robinson
  2. Biggio
  3. Sandberg
  4. Cano (HRD)
  5. Murphy

Third Basemen

  1. Chipper Jones
  2. Donaldson
  3. Nolan Jones
  4. Rendon
  5. Gorman

Shortstop

  1. Tatis
  2. Turner
  3. Bichette
  4. Story
  5. Gregorius

Left Field

  1. Williams
  2. Yelich
  3. Henderson
  4. Trammel
  5. Brock

Centerfield

  1. Mantle
  2. Trout
  3. Cobb
  4. Lofton
  5. Kemp

Right Field

  1. Ruth
  2. Walker
  3. Harper
  4. Musial
SDS

My picks are ONLY based off cards ive used. If they arent listed, i dont have them or haven't used them yet.

Starting Pitcher

  1. Awards Kluber
  2. POTM Paxton
  3. Awards Seaver
  4. FS Pearson
  5. SS Newhouser

Relief Pitcher

  1. SS Rivera
  2. SS Wagner
  3. Awards Gagne
  4. SS Hoffman
  5. Prime Wade Davis

Catcher

  1. Prestige Posey
  2. SS Posada
  3. TN D'Arnaud
  4. POTM Grandal
  5. Awards Perez

First Basemen

  1. SS Lou Gehrig
  2. Awards Ortiz
  3. Prime Thomas
  4. POTM Bellinger
  5. SS Encarnacion

Second Basemen

  1. Awards Hornsby
  2. SS Jackie Robinson
  3. HRD Cano
  4. SS Sandberg
  5. SS Biggio

Third Basemen

  1. Awards Rendon
  2. TN Brad Miller
  3. Awards Longoria
  4. FS Gorman
  5. TN Shaw

Shortstop

  1. POTM Tatis
  2. SS Rollins
  3. Awards Larkin
  4. TN Turner
  5. TN Bo Bichette

Left Field

  1. SS Ted Williams
  2. Awards Yelich
  3. FOTF Brock
  4. POTM Winker
  5. Prime Minoso

Centerfield

  1. Awards Trout
  2. Prime Cobb
  3. Prime Mantle
  4. HRD Griffey
  5. SS Lofton

Right Field

  1. Awards Babe
  2. SS Walker
  3. Awards Musial
  4. Awards Sheffield
  5. Prime Reggie Jackson
SDS

Catcher

  1. TN Jorge Alfaro
  2. SS Jorge Posada
  3. Awards Weiters
  4. Awards Posey
  5. FS Joey Bart
SDS

I like this idea.
Note: These are just cards that I have used.

Starting Pitcher

  1. Orel Hershiser
  2. Corey Kluber
  3. Clayton Kershaw
  4. Tom Seaver
  5. Chris Sale

Relief Pitcher

  1. Goose Gossage
  2. Kenley Jansen
  3. Rob Dibble
  4. Aroldis Chapman
  5. Rollie Fingers

Catcher

  1. Jorge Posada
  2. Joey Bart
  3. Matt Wieters
  4. Joe Torre
  5. Buster Posey

First Basemen

  1. Jimmie Foxx
  2. David Ortiz
  3. Cody Bellinger
  4. Jim Thome
  5. Frank Thomas

Second Basemen

  1. Rogers Hornsby
  2. Robinson Cano
  3. Craig Biggio
  4. Javier Baez
  5. Ryne Sandberg

Third Basemen

  1. Chipper Jones
  2. George Brett
  3. Jose Ramirez
  4. Mike Schmidt
  5. Kris Bryant

Shortstop

  1. Fernando Tatis Jr.
  2. Honus Wagner
  3. Ernie Banks
  4. Didi Gregorius
  5. Bo Bichette

Left Field

  1. Lou Brock
  2. Ted Williams
  3. Dylan Carson
  4. Juan Soto
  5. Minnie Minoso

Centerfield

  1. Mickey Mantle
  2. Ty Cobb
  3. Mike Trout
  4. Luis Robert
  5. George Springer

Right Field

  1. Larry Walker
  2. Babe Ruth
  3. Stan Musial
  4. Gary Sheffield
  5. Nicholas Castellanos
SDS

Starting Pitcher

  1. Feller
  2. Maddux
  3. Hershisers
  4. Sale
  5. Seaver

Relief Pitcher

  1. Goose
  2. Wagner
  3. Rivera
  4. Dibble
  5. Chapman

Catcher (havent used Piazza)

  1. Pudge
  2. Weiters
  3. Posada
  4. Torre
  5. Joey Bart FS?

First Basemen (secondary 1b included)

  1. Gehrig
  2. Ruth
  3. Thomas
  4. Musial
  5. Thames

Second Basemen

  1. Hornsby
  2. Prestige Biggio
  3. 99 Jackie
  4. Non prestige Biggio
  5. Cano(higher if you only play on AS)

Third Basemen

  1. 99 Pujols (he should be played at 3rd)
  2. 99 Donaldson
  3. 96 Chipper
  4. 99 Brett
  5. 94 Chipper

Shortstop

  1. Tatis (prestiged or not)
  2. Rollins
  3. Yount
  4. Didi
  5. Jazz Chisholm

Left Field

  1. Ted Williams
  2. 99 Rickey Henderson
  3. Lou Brock
  4. Dylan Carlson FS
  5. Secondary CF's play LF on most teams. I use Cobb.

Centerfield

  1. Prestige Mantle
  2. 99 Trout
  3. Non prestige mantle
  4. Eric Davis
  5. Kenny Lofton

Right Field

  1. Larry Walker
  2. Prestige Sheff (should be at 3rd on most teams)
  3. Bryce Harper
  4. Tony Gwynn
  5. Al Kaline
SDS

Starting Pitcher

  1. SS Chris Sale
  2. HW Tom Seaver
  3. SS Nolan Ryan
  4. SS Hal Newhouser
  5. SS Bob Feller

Relief Pitcher

  1. Prime Rob Dibble
  2. Prime Jake McGee
  3. SS Billy Wagner
  4. Prestige Mariano Rivera
  5. HW Rollie Fingers

Catcher

  1. SS Jorge Posada
  2. HW Mike Piazza
  3. SS Joe Torre
  4. HW Matt Wieters
  5. Prospect Zack Collins

First Basemen

  1. Prestige Jim Thome
  2. Prime Ryan Klesko
  3. HW Albert Pujols
  4. AS Fred McGriff
  5. HW David Ortiz

Second Basemen

  1. HW Roberto Alomar
  2. HRD Robinson Cano
  3. MA Brandon Lowe
  4. SS Jackie Robinson
  5. HW Daniel Murphy

Third Basemen

  1. Prestige Chipper Jones
  2. Finest Jose Ramirez
  3. FS Nolan Jones
  4. TN Travis Shaw
  5. FS Nolan Gorman

Shortstop

  1. SS Jimmy Rollins
  2. TN Bo Bichette
  3. MA Didi Gregorius
  4. HW Ernie Banks
  5. SS Hanley Ramirez

Left Field

  1. SS Ted Williams
  2. BO Adam Dunn
  3. TN Yordan Alvarez
  4. LS Joey Gallo
  5. MA Teoscar Hernandez

Centerfield

  1. HW Mike Trout
  2. SS Kenny Lofton
  3. Prime Mickey Mantle
  4. PS Ken Griffey Jr
  5. Prime Jacoby Ellsbury

Right Field

  1. Prestige Larry Walker
  2. HW Babe Ruth
  3. Prestige Gary Sheffield
  4. HW Bryce Harper
  5. HW Vladimir Guerrero
SDS

Some of these are limited time, but I am liking how they play.
Like @skywalker_25, These are cards I have used
I use a lot of secondary's. 🙂
Starting Pitcher

  1. Alec Mills 99 TN
  2. 98 Hal Newhouser
  3. 99 James Paxton
  4. 99 Kluber
  5. 90 Players League Lucas Giolito

Relief Pitcher

  1. 94 POTM James Karinchak
  2. 95 POTM Edwin Diaz
  3. 89 LS Josh Hader
  4. 85 Players Tournament Amir Garrett
  5. 93 TN Tyler Alexander
    Yes, I do not have many high diamonds in my bullpen. 🙂

Catcher

  1. 94 Salvador Perez (Hits above his stats, GREAT cheap catcher)
  2. 96 Jorge Posada (I sold him to get Kris Bryant, but still a great catcher, just more expensive that Perez) 🙂
  3. 90 Yasmani Grandal
  4. 86 LS J.T. Realmuto

First Basemen

  1. 97 POTM Bellinger (Normally in the outfield)
  2. 89 FOTF Rizzo (Hits really well for me, love his swing, normally starts) I have had Rizzo starting since week 1.
  3. 90 Wille Stargell
  4. LS Matt Olsen (In BR or showdown, great pick. Haven't gotten FOTF)

Second Basemen

  1. 98 Bo Bichette TN
  2. 97 Javy Baez (Tried him in showdown, can't wait to get him)
  3. 99 Sandberg (Started off REALLY well for me, fell of a cliff, so he is now on the bench for me)
  4. 93 FS Nico Hoerner
  5. 88 POTM Jonathan Schoop

Third Basemen

  1. 97 Kris Bryant MVP
  2. LS Bregman I messed around with Bregman and Chapman. I otherwise had secondary 3rd basemen.
  3. LS Matt Chapman
  4. LS Kris Bryant (Until I got a diamond, he raked for me, better than most of my diamonds)

Shortstop

  1. 99 Tatis
  2. 92 Hanley Ramirez
  3. 89 Trevor Story
  4. 89 Trea Turner
  5. 85 LS Javier Baez

Left Field

  1. 97 Jesse Winker POTM
  2. 94 Teoscar Hernandez POTM
  3. 92 Dave Kingman

Centerfield I am hoping we get a finest Ian Happ. If so, he will take over as number one. 🙂

  1. 98 Cristian Pache FS
  2. 99 Andruw Jones (I have only used him for a few games in showdown, but doing really well so far. That is why Pache is higher)
  3. 92 Kyle Lewis POTM
  4. 93 Ramon Laureano POTM
  5. 88 Players League Ian Happ

Right Field

  1. 90 LS Aaron Judge (Normally have POTM Bellinger
  2. 93 LS Mookie Betts
  3. 86 Players league Joey Gallo
  4. Was LS Yelich, but he has gotten worse. 🙂
  5. 88 Bryce Harper
SDS

Just guys I've used
Sp

  1. Seaver
  2. Ryan
  3. Wood
  4. Blyleven
  5. Oswalt

RP

  1. 94 Wagner
  2. Fingers
  3. Dibble
  4. Crochet
  5. Diaz

1B

  1. Helton
  2. Bagwell
  3. McCovey
  4. Encarnacion
  5. Mattingly

2b

  1. Hornsby
  2. Biggio
  3. Carew

Ss

  1. Tatis
  2. Bichette
  3. Correa
  4. Turner
  5. Hanley

3b

  1. Chipper (He might be the only third baseman I've used for more than a couple games) Usually play SS at 3rd

LF

  1. Yordon Alvarez
  2. Winker
  3. Brantley

Cf

  1. Cobb
  2. LS Trout
  3. PS Springer

RF

  1. Walker
  2. Harper
  3. Gwynn
  4. Jackson
SDS

Starting Pitcher
1.Kluber
2.Orel
3.Maddux
4.Lodolo
5.Hal

Relief Pitcher
1.SS Chapman
2.Dibble
3.Gagne
4.AS Wagner
5.Fingers

Catcher
1.Posey
2.Piazza
3.Pudge
4.Yadi
5.MA Sanchez (Lots of early success)

First Basemen
1.Foxx
2.Gehrig
3.Thomas
4.Ortiz
5.Pujols

Second Basemen
1.Jackie
2.Hornsby
3.Alomar
4.Cano
5.Biggio

Third Basemen
1.Donaldson
2.Chipper
3.Nolan Jones
4.Killebrew
5.

Shortstop
1.Tatis
2.Wagner
3.J-Roll
4.Smith
5.

Left Field
1.Williams
2.Winker
3.Henderson
4.Lou Brock
5.

Centerfield
1.Mantle
2.Trout
3.Cobb
4. Ellsbury
5. Davis

Right Field
1.Walker
2. Babe
3.Sheff
4.Harper
5. Gywnn

Log in to reply