Harper is 1000x better than Trout

SDS

Sucks I had to spend 1m stubs to figure it out lol

Edit: I should have known, I could never hit with any trout dating back to 17 I know its a personal preference thing. Idk why I thought this trout would be different lol.

Ah well, Trout to the bench and Harper back to right.

SDS

Well to me awards Trout is the best card in MLBTS history and this year's Harper doesn't even make my bench. So its definitely a personal preference thing.

SDS

@raesONE said in Harper is 1000x better than Trout:

Well to me awards Trout is the best card in MLBTS history and this year's Harper doesn't even make my bench. So its definitely a personal preference thing.

Lol, Mantle's swing is suspect so I'll agree on the Trout take.

SDS

I don't have a huge sample size for Harper, but he does have better stats than Trout for me.

SDS

@raesONE said in Harper is 1000x better than Trout:

Well to me awards Trout is the best card in MLBTS history and this year's Harper doesn't even make my bench. So its definitely a personal preference thing.

I have loved every one of trouts cards and as soon as I get him each year he doesn’t leave my lineup. His swing just works for me. I think this years is by far the best version and he won’t leave my lineup but I think this mantle card has to be the best card in the history of the show.

SDS

@pfcorporate said in Harper is 1000x better than Trout:

@raesONE said in Harper is 1000x better than Trout:

Well to me awards Trout is the best card in MLBTS history and this year's Harper doesn't even make my bench. So its definitely a personal preference thing.

I have loved every one of trouts cards and as soon as I get him each year he doesn’t leave my lineup. His swing just works for me. I think this years is by far the best version and he won’t leave my lineup but I think this mantle card has to be the best card in the history of the show.

I don't like Mantle's swing. It's great for pitches low in the zone, but his batting stance and slowish swing doesn't translate well on pitches high in the zone. Trout on the other mashes everything, it doesn't matter where you pitch the ball to him.

SDS

I still think Awards Trout is the best card in the game but I can't remove Harper from my lineup either and he's pushed Walker to the bench. Everything Awards Harper hits is crushed (5 homeruns in 8 games I believe)

SDS

Trout hits better than any card all year. Mantle Prestiged is right there too

SDS

I like both cards but Trout is the better card. Everything he touches is smoked!

SDS

I bought Ted Williams after I bought Harper and yea I had more success with Harper. Ted is great but that price tag doesn’t seem to warrant when Harper was just as good

SDS

@raesONE said in Harper is 1000x better than Trout:

@pfcorporate said in Harper is 1000x better than Trout:

@raesONE said in Harper is 1000x better than Trout:

Well to me awards Trout is the best card in MLBTS history and this year's Harper doesn't even make my bench. So its definitely a personal preference thing.

I have loved every one of trouts cards and as soon as I get him each year he doesn’t leave my lineup. His swing just works for me. I think this years is by far the best version and he won’t leave my lineup but I think this mantle card has to be the best card in the history of the show.

I don't like Mantle's swing. It's great for pitches low in the zone, but his batting stance and slowish swing doesn't translate well on pitches high in the zone. Trout on the other mashes everything, it doesn't matter where you pitch the ball to him.

Side note if you haven’t tried jo adell he’s a fun card. I have a secondary account that I play on with a more budget team and his swing reminds me of a lot of trout. I never would have tried him if not for the second account but it forced me to put him on my bench on main account.

SDS

Trout absolutely smokes everything low and in, up and in anything away and is awesome. I hit great with Harper in the showdown but I didn’t get him. My outfield of Cobb Trout and Mantle is pretty hard to beat. Now with that said WTF is Willie Mays? So disappointed he is not out yet

SDS

Trout has been better for me, but Harper isn't far behind. Harper has been better than Ruth for me, although I don't start Harper against lefties.

SDS

I never hit well with Trout either until this year. Lots of cards this year have different results from their swings.

SDS

Trout and Tatis are something else with their early swings. Most diamond cards crush the ball on P/P but those 2 are insane on poor feedback too.

SDS

For the last 5 years, I based my RTTS swing on Trout's. He's one of the few guys I can hit with in RS.

SDS

@raesONE said in Harper is 1000x better than Trout:

Well to me awards Trout is the best card in MLBTS history and this year's Harper doesn't even make my bench. So its definitely a personal preference thing.

yep i feel the same way he carried me on my last RS game

SDS

99 trout is the best card hands down, even before you prestige him.

SDS

This is my first year with trout and his batting .307 with 25 HR. And Harper Hitting .287 with 23 HR . Harper has been hitting fly balls lately he usually stays above .300 I love both of them though, both end game players for though I’m not a big fan of trout I’ll keep him for his production

SDS

I didn't believe Awards Trout was any better than LS Trout initially, but I bucked up and put in the stubs to get him. Best card to me so far. Everything I hit is nuked. All of my HRs are 430 plus with him

Log in to reply