Your browser does not seem to support JavaScript. As a result, your viewing experience will be diminished, and you may not be able to execute some actions.
Please download a browser that supports JavaScript, or enable it if it's disabled (i.e. NoScript).
Who’s the best SS between the two ?
Honus looks like a Mama's boy IMOP! He made two errors in one play tonight, so he got the boot for Tatis. Too bad too cuz I spent thousands on him. Oh well. Besides, who would name their kid Honus??? LOL
@ThaGhettoBlasta said in Tatis vs Wagner:
My man I’m so sorry for your tragedy. Wait ... Honus has diamond defense. How that’s possible ?
Tats for me
LOL...I thought the same thing, then he threw a ball into the stands. Tatis never did that to me. But again, he'll probably start tomorrow.
@lazy_toast said in Tatis vs Wagner:
So what’s so special about Tatis ? He is a god or something ?
Might have been a popular name back then.
You can ask the same about naming a daughter Agnes or Agatha or Bathsheba or Yekatherine.
@TheGoaler said in Tatis vs Wagner:
@ThaGhettoBlasta said in Tatis vs Wagner: Honus looks like a Mama's boy IMOP! He made two errors in one play tonight, so he got the boot for Tatis. Too bad too cuz I spent thousands on him. Oh well. Besides, who would name their kid Honus??? LOL Might have been a popular name back then. You can ask the same about naming a daughter Agnes or Agatha or Bathsheba or Yekatherine.
Honus honestly has disappointed me. Maybe my expectations were too high. Tatis rakes for me. The guy hits tanks and when he does not he has the speed to leg out a base hit or stretch a single into a double. Honus just does not have enough pop but he is similar to Jackie in that he is a basehit machine. I'm also playing Seager/ Mookie over Wagner at 2b. Joram is at 3rd until I get Machado. So Honus is basically like the best bench guy you can have but never a starter.
@TheGoaler said in Tatis vs Wagner: @ThaGhettoBlasta said in Tatis vs Wagner: Honus looks like a Mama's boy IMOP! He made two errors in one play tonight, so he got the boot for Tatis. Too bad too cuz I spent thousands on him. Oh well. Besides, who would name their kid Honus??? LOL Might have been a popular name back then. You can ask the same about naming a daughter Agnes or Agatha or Bathsheba or Yekatherine.
His parents were German immigrants, so that might explain the seemingly different name.
I didn’t love honus last year but I picked him up this year for the event on a second account. Small sample size but through 35 at bats he’s hitting over 600. I think only one homerun so power isn’t there yet but I feel like every at is either a base hot up the middle or a missile in the gap. I was planning on locking in cards to get finest Lindor but I may just stick with honus this year. For me it always comes down to swing animation. I didn’t love tatis swing and feel really comfortable with honus.
AS difficulty - Tatis HOF difficulty - Wagner
Tatis is a two outcome hitter for me. His prestige version is hitting 290 with a 40% strikeout rate. All but 6 of his hits are extra base hits
I actually play them both. Honus at SS and Tatis at 2nd.
@lvega127 said in Tatis vs Wagner:
Good man.
Tatis is really streaky for me , just when I'm about to bench him and he's dropping in the order he'll go on a 3 to 4 hit streak for a few games . and hits moonshots. His defense alone will save you runs
So I have been very pleasantly surprised by how well Honus has been hitting for me as I played him regularly in the last event and look forward to finishing prestiging him in this next one. Not "sure" yet if he will win the 2B job on my primary team (Red Tatis has SS locked down) but I hit much better with Honus than Seager/Finest Lindor/Ramirez/etc. With so many juiced cards I figure I don't need everyone to be a HR hitter as a 2R-HR is better than a solo.
Seager is better than both
@Thierry007007 said in Tatis vs Wagner:
Tatis. Unless you do not like home runs and want the extra speed.
@CubsFan708 said in Tatis vs Wagner:
Seager has a weaker arm and should be at second.
