Choosing between Posada and Gagne

Which way would you lean? Just curious how these two have played for some of you. I’m pretty set with my team but catcher is always up in the air for me and looking to replace Jansen in my pen. Thanks

Gagne without a doubt.

Both are great, honestly just depends if you want a catcher or a bullpen arm, can't really go wrong with either one

I love Posada, best catcher I've used all year. Gagne is the second-best righty imo after Jansen.
Like Skepple said, just depends on need.

Small sample only 23 AB with Posada but he hits clutch so far. Only hitting .217 but he has hit 2 doubles and 1 hr all with runners on. His speed is the only knock so far as a single won’t get him home from second most of the time and he does allow more passed [censored] than Realmuto.

I think the perfect combination is starting him and have Realmuto on the bench. If Posada gets on base in the 7th or later sub in Realmuto and now you have speed and great defense. So far liking this card.

PS: Hahahaha I seriously can’t type ballz (but the correct spelling) on a board about baseball?? Haha

would a maxed out CAP not be equivalent to posada with better D? just put his swing on and take gagne.

@Ryan_2713 said in Choosing between Posada and Gagne:

would a maxed out CAP not be equivalent to posada with better D? just put his swing on and take gagne.

Possibly I guess it depends on the quirks. I have not started creating a CAP this year

Could you please keep playing BR? We need more flawless rewards in the ecosystem.

Man, I’m stub rich like everyone. I just can’t bring myself to spend that much on Gagne. And he’s about the only guy I really want and it’s still too much for me. Rather just have some fun mixing and matching different guys.

Log in to reply