Level 1 Silver

I am stuck right now and have no idea on who to choose at the level 1 XP reward. Honestly don't have any good players currently but I am working towards getting FOTF Gallo and Torres so that's that. Also, I have my created player at third. I have Gallo and Bryce harper in the corners and Gold Gleyber at 2nd with Machado at third. I see that stats-wise Sandberg would probably be best but I heard from many people that his swing isn't good and he doesn't play up to his stats. Please help 🙂

No one care.. game trash

There probably won’t be a better overall catcher this year than that 99 Posey.

@DaMightyRandom said in Level 1 Silver:

No one care.. game trash

Solid input.

For the OP, I’m taking Larkin first.

I took Sandberg and haven't had any issues.

@e_santos1998 said in Level 1 Silver:

I am stuck right now and have no idea on who to choose at the level 1 XP reward. Honestly don't have any good players currently but I am working towards getting FOTF Gallo and Torres so that's that. Also, I have my created player at third. I have Gallo and Bryce harper in the corners and Gold Gleyber at 2nd with Machado at third. I see that stats-wise Sandberg would probably be best but I heard from many people that his swing isn't good and he doesn't play up to his stats. Please help 🙂

Im debating just like you are at the moment and im stuck between posey and larkin. Posey would be the better upgrade but larkin would allow me to sell my current SS and finish some collections decisions lol

@casedogg310 said in Level 1 Silver:

There probably won’t be a better overall catcher this year than that 99 Posey.

I really like posey and he was going to be my main choice but... with my history with catchers in MLB the show is that they cant hit no matter what stats they have. Maybe it's just me but I don't want to risk it. I'm already a level 10 silver and haven't opened it yet because I want to see if anyone chooses posey and has success with him.

@e_santos1998 said in Level 1 Silver:

I am stuck right now and have no idea on who to choose at the level 1 XP reward. Honestly don't have any good players currently but I am working towards getting FOTF Gallo and Torres so that's that. Also, I have my created player at third. I have Gallo and Bryce harper in the corners and Gold Gleyber at 2nd with Machado at third. I see that stats-wise Sandberg would probably be best but I heard from many people that his swing isn't good and he doesn't play up to his stats. Please help 🙂

I took Reggie. The speed is the most surprising part as he appears faster than a 71, and the swing is smooth too. He also has a decent arm.

@e_santos1998 said in Level 1 Silver:

@casedogg310 said in Level 1 Silver:

There probably won’t be a better overall catcher this year than that 99 Posey.

I really like posey and he was going to be my main choice but... with my history with catchers in MLB the show is that they cant hit no matter what stats they have. Maybe it's just me but I don't want to risk it. I'm already a level 10 silver and haven't opened it yet because I want to see if anyone chooses posey and has success with him.

Im using the 87 gary sanchez right now and his stats are way misleading he absolutely mashes

@THE_Tomdawg69er said in Level 1 Silver:

@e_santos1998 said in Level 1 Silver:

I am stuck right now and have no idea on who to choose at the level 1 XP reward. Honestly don't have any good players currently but I am working towards getting FOTF Gallo and Torres so that's that. Also, I have my created player at third. I have Gallo and Bryce harper in the corners and Gold Gleyber at 2nd with Machado at third. I see that stats-wise Sandberg would probably be best but I heard from many people that his swing isn't good and he doesn't play up to his stats. Please help 🙂

I took Reggie. The speed is the most surprising part as he appears faster than a 71, and the swing is smooth too. He also has a decent arm.

Has he made any errors because I'm worried about his fielding? I have heard that he smashes though.

Reggie Jackson hits just as good as Mantle or Trout.

I just finished FOTF Correa and Im at level 84.(Shouldve went Matt Olsen before Correa but oh well). Im going Larkin tho and moving Correa to 2nd. Or Mondesi at 2nd.

Nearly there myself and its between Ryno & Minnie.

@casedogg310 said in Level 1 Silver:

There probably won’t be a better overall catcher this year than that 99 Posey.

There is already one named Craig Biggio.

@e_santos1998 said in Level 1 Silver:

@THE_Tomdawg69er said in Level 1 Silver:

@e_santos1998 said in Level 1 Silver:

I am stuck right now and have no idea on who to choose at the level 1 XP reward. Honestly don't have any good players currently but I am working towards getting FOTF Gallo and Torres so that's that. Also, I have my created player at third. I have Gallo and Bryce harper in the corners and Gold Gleyber at 2nd with Machado at third. I see that stats-wise Sandberg would probably be best but I heard from many people that his swing isn't good and he doesn't play up to his stats. Please help 🙂

I took Reggie. The speed is the most surprising part as he appears faster than a 71, and the swing is smooth too. He also has a decent arm.

Has he made any errors because I'm worried about his fielding? I have heard that he smashes though.

He bobbled a ground ball thru the infield but kept it in front, then the no lock on thing glitches a ball by him for a double, but the next play he threw the runner out ragging up

@louieepthree said in Level 1 Silver:

I just finished FOTF Correa and Im at level 84.(Shouldve went Matt Olsen before Correa but oh well). Im going Larkin tho and moving Correa to 2nd. Or Mondesi at 2nd.

Does that Correa have a 3B secondary?

@THE_Tomdawg69er said in Level 1 Silver:

@louieepthree said in Level 1 Silver:

I just finished FOTF Correa and Im at level 84.(Shouldve went Matt Olsen before Correa but oh well). Im going Larkin tho and moving Correa to 2nd. Or Mondesi at 2nd.

Does that Correa have a 3B secondary?

Yep 2B, 3B, and I’ve heard he can work a video room.

@turtleopolis said in Level 1 Silver:

@THE_Tomdawg69er said in Level 1 Silver:

@louieepthree said in Level 1 Silver:

I just finished FOTF Correa and Im at level 84.(Shouldve went Matt Olsen before Correa but oh well). Im going Larkin tho and moving Correa to 2nd. Or Mondesi at 2nd.

Does that Correa have a 3B secondary?

Yep 2B, 3B, and I’ve heard he can work a video room.

Lol imagine they gave all the Astros a quirk called “A/V guy”

I’m going with Minnie because of my Sox bias, but Larkin looks like a great choice. I remember really hurting for middle infielders last year until about June, so getting a solid shortstop in March is a huge advantage.

I went with Ryne Sandberg

Log in to reply